Rose & Crown or Tutto Italia

[courtneymarieclare]

We (DBF & myself) have lunch reservations for NYE at Tutto Italia. Today as I was browsing, I came across a reservation for Rose & Crown, also for lunch. I booked that too, so now I have a decision to make: stay with Tutto or go with Rose & Crown. What would you do?

We are not on the dining plan if that influences your decision.

Also, our dinner reservations are not until 10:30 p.m. The Tutto reservation is at 11:30 a.m., the R & C at 2:00 p.m.

Thanks in advance!

 

[abubu919]

We (DBF & myself) have lunch reservations for NYE at Tutto Italia. Today as I was browsing, I came across a reservation for Rose & Crown, also for lunch. I booked that too, so now I have a decision to make: stay with Tutto or go with Rose & Crown. What would you do?

We are not on the dining plan if that influences your decision.

Also, our dinner reservations are not until 10:30 p.m. The Tutto reservation is at 11:30 a.m., the R & C at 2:00 p.m.

Thanks in advance!

I'd pick Rose and Crown. We loved it and we were also not on the DDP. It was affordable and had a wide variety of food selection. Also since your dinner is so late, it is probably better to have a later lunch.

 

[BingBang]

For our family, it's definitely Tutto. That's always a must-do for us every trip. The atmosphere is pretty elegant for NYE and the food is fabulous. Gets my vote!

 

[Pooh Bear Hugs]

The Rose and Crown food is awful which is sad as I'd love some nice British pub food while away.

 

[disneypolybride2008]

i would stick with Tutto, it's amazing! The prices are very high though, if your not on the ddp. They do have some cheaper lunch items but the dinner like entrees are $$$. I am trying Rose and Crown this visit, their menu looked great-for dinner. Have a great time!

 

[chocovrdmicears]

We have eaten at both.
We definately didn't love R & C...food was 'meh' at best. I would be willing to give it another try but my kids wouldn't eat anything they now have on the kids menu.
We have eaten at Tutto twice and loved both our meals. But I think they are waaaaay overpriced so I am not sure I would eat there if I wasn't on the dining plan.

 

[rebster]

Rose and Crown!

We have always enjoyed eating there and our meal at Italy was our worst meal of our trip and the only one we had complaints about. The food is brought out so quickly you hardly have a chance to enjoy a glass of wine or chatting. But if you like the quick in and out meal, then you may like Italy.

Rose and Crown has great food, and I have never felt rushed there, and its more of a comfort food type place which is really nice for one meal at Disney.