Unfortunately, DBF's must visit and my must visit list are not the same! (But I am also new enough to Disney that I am still trying out a new places)
His must visits are:
CG--He just thinks it's "the Best" and being able to take someone to "the best" is very important. He does like the filet and the fireworks
and
Le Cellier--I think it's just nostalgia from when it used to be great and his son loves it.
Mine would be
Jiko--Romance, good food, and great location. I was awed the first time I walked into AKL and I just loved the feel of Jiko.
and
Flying Fish-Red Snapper and BEST service I have ever had at WDW. I have TIW, where 18% gratuity is included, and I added an additional 10% because my waiter was that good.
Luckily, he loved Jiko when I dragged him there last year, and I do really like California Grill...I am trying to figure out how to avoid going to Le Cellier in October (It's good, but I rather try a dozen other restaurants!)