quality inn maingate west vs comfort inn lake buena vista - HELP PLEASE!

[sundayschild]

hi guys,

read reviews from tripadvisor, but would really appreciate your help. i can't decide between these two - both fit our budget, have continental breakfast and shuttles, which are what we need - otherwise they're just places to sleep. i can get both for around the same price - but would appreciate if anyone who has stayed at either place recently could please tell me about your experiences??

THANK YOU! this is urgent - any help is appreciated!

 

[AlienBrain]

I stayed at the Quality Inn for a week this past New Years Eve. It was fine. A typical hotel stay. The rooms have outside entry if that is OK with you, but the outside entry is in an open courtyard, so it isn't bad at all in my opinion. There was no excessive noise. The rooms were clean.

The pool is great if you are staying during a warm time of year (we have stayed there during a warm time before). There are free drinks at the cabana style bar every evening which is kinda cool.

In summation, it is a good hotel. Not bad, not great ... just decent. Oh yeah, and the breakfast is pretty good (hard boiled eggs, cereal, bagels, english muffins, waffles, fruit, juice, and coffee)

 

[BonnieA]

Since you haven't gotten too many replies on this, I'll give my two cents. I've stayed in both. They were both clean, convenient, mostly quiet. If both were the same price, I would pick the comfort inn, only because there is a microwave and fridge in the room. But if you do pick that one, make sure and request a parking lot view otherwise you will be facing noisy I 4. Quality Inn has a convenient back entrance off Black Lake Rd which leads to Sherberth Rd and the back entrance to disney. They do close that entrance late at night and you'll have to go around to the front in that case. Comfort Inn has a gated entrance with a guard.

 

[lynn71092]

My sister and I just stayed at the Comfort Inn Lake Buena Vista on April 12th-15th. The only problem we had was the drainage in our shower/bathtub was very slow. Other than that, the room was great and although I did not reserve the room with the microwave & refrigerator they were in our room at our original rate of $63.00/night. (I booked through Southwest Airlines website so I could get a Rapid Rewards credit.). The staff was very nice. As for the free continental breakfast it was so crowded that we only did it one day, otherwise we just got something at the parks. If you PM me I can send you a couple of pictures of our room. Overall, I would stay there again!