Well, I for one, have mixed feelings about this new policy. I agree to some extent w/those of you who have said that you should just do everything once and then by the time you have done everything once it should be 3. But I also must say that my DH will not ride a lot of things there. He does not do coasters or things with big drops. He really enjoys MIB, Popeye, and Spiderman. When we go, we always do those over and over. So, we had been planning to stay on site during our next trip for the FOTL priveleges so that we could do those over and over w/very little wait. I really can't see paying so much $$$ for a hotel if we can't use the FOTL over and over. If it was just me, it would not matter, b/c I am fine w/doing everything. But it will completely ruin my DH's trip.
I won't stop going to Universal. I will probably just consider staying offsite (unless this policy changes...praying for that!), and paying for a cheaper hotel. I would rather buy express booklets since it would be the same as the new onsite FOTL policy and would be cheaper for us.
Oh, and as far as Disney, I don't understand why everyone has to compare that to US. They are both very different. So, why argue over which is better, cheaper, has more benefits, etc.? I enjoy both and I also don't mind paying the extra $10 for e-Nights as Metallicat mentioned. Both parks have different things to offer, so I am not even going to start the comparisons. Just wanted to let everyone know that it is silly to argue over that. Sorry if this offends anyone!