I think everyone is generalizing fastpass too much. It works for some people and not for others. I originally was just wondering if anyone had heard any rumblings about it coming back, not really everyone's opinions on if it should.
Before the pandemic, insiders on other boards were hinting at a paid system being launched at some point. Then the closures and Disney announcing no FP upon reopening. That is all the information we’ve had for the last year. It’s a message board...with no concrete information, people are going to speculate and give their opinions.
No one is generalizing here anyway. People who actually measure wait times at the parks for a living, collecting and analyzing data, have written extensively on the negative impact on FP+ on standby waits. Like with math and everything. This isn’t a debatable subject, it’s demonstrable with hard facts. I loved it from a selfish standpoint because I knew how to work it, but if you didn’t? Oof.
More than that, even the people for whom this broken system worked (the minority of guests who are parks obsessives on the internet, aka me and half the people on these boards), it didn’t work 100% of the time. No matter how many rolling FPs you can get in a day, eventually you’re going to end up in a standby line at some point, being held while 30 people in the FP+ queue get waved through. It contributed to the mad rush at rope drop because people in the know understood there was a very small window to get headliners in before standby waits built to untenable lengths. Local APs and offsite guests, even onsite guests on shorter trips, basically couldn’t ride FoP or Slinky Dog except at rope drop or park close in standby. Not to mention leading up to the closures, even if you knew all the tricks, refreshing was getting harder and harder to do, because of increased crowds competing for FPs, and methods getting publicized. Folks who go regularly had been talking about that for a while before the closures, even.
The system as it was just was not working except for a small minority of people, and was growing untenable even for them, and that’s not a great way to run a theme park resort.