I am not a horror movie fan (not that I'm "scared" of them, but I think they're mostly just really awful movies), but I really loved Orphan last year.
Foolish me, I ended up watching over 200 movies released in 2009 last year (my journey can be found in my blog which is linked below [shameless self-promotion over]) and Orphan landed in spot #14. Here was my silly write-up in my end-of-the year wrap-up:
Dear Vera Farmiga,
Oh, Vera. You are probably my favorite actress working today. I realize you probably felt like you were "stooping" to a new low in this horror film, but you helped raise Orphan from simply an average flick to one that I've already enjoyed on multiple viewings.
You were certainly aided by Peter Sarsgaard as your husband and young Isabelle Fuhrman as your freakish adopted daughter. Plus, while the script had a tad too many typical "fake" horror scares, it still has some major twists that through me for a loop.
In the end, though, it is your nuanced performance (yes, I realize this was simply a horror movie, but I feel like that's an honest assessment about your role) that stands out and will make me return to this fun flick multiple times.
Yours truly,
RyMickey
I really liked it a lot, so you're not alone!