OK, is your user name "Carol's not" or "Carol snot"?

Just kidding with you, but that's what I read.
I really enjoy Key West. Very easy, laid-back atmosphere. We had a 1-bed and I loved the colors.

We had not requested a water view, but did have a large pond near the room that we could see when sitting on the patio.
I liked Olivia's well enough, but actually would rather get a tuna sandwich or a burger at Good's to Go and sit on the patio, by the water.

At night, they played island music on that patio (not the God of island music himself, if you happen to be a parrothead, but it was great all the same.)
The only thing I didn't like was getting stuck behind the towel carts while driving through the resort.
I wouldn't get a refillable mug. If you aren't close (and even if you are), you probably won't feel like heading over there every time you want a few more ounces of pop. You CAN use them in any resort now. So, if you'll be switching to the Poly or visiting the AKL, you could fill on up.
I prefer hotels and the whole hotel thing, so I don't stay there a whole bunch, but highly recommend OKW!