Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

[Nancy]

They had too - they are out promoting their new album. It wouldn't look good if they were booing their own song.

I wouldn't buy it either way!

 

[DVC-Don]

Carrie and Vonzell have been the best so far tonight.

 

[LadyBears]

Lets see how Constantine does with this...... either it will be wicked good or wicked bad there can be no inbetween with this one........

 

[orangeblossom]

It was really good, but I hate that song.

 

[Disney1fan2002]

Lets see how Constantine does with this...... either it will be wicked good or wicked bad there can be no inbetween with this one........

My vote, wicked BAD! UgH.

This is second time out of the gate as Freddy Mercury, isn't it?

 

[LadyBears]

Constantine did the best tonight. Awesome mix for the song!!!!!!
Carrie & Bo both also rocked it hard tonight. I see a trend......

 

[StaceyA]

my opinion was Constantine was the best.....but could he make love to that camera more?? LOL

Seriously, Constantine is getting better every week I think.

 

[disneyworldgirl]

8. Constantine-- "Bohemian Rhapsody"-- Great start; looks like he's incorporating some of his theatrical training! Very good; one of the top three tonight.

BTW, I thought Paula was going to jump right out of her shirt when Simon gave Constantine the thumbs-up!

 

[Nancy]

Lets see how Constantine does with this...... either it will be wicked good or wicked bad there can be no inbetween with this one........

I choose wicked bad! Please no more closeups!

 

[palmtreegirl]

My thoughts-

Nadia- Sounds good but I've never heard this song, it's a bit boring. Is it just me or is her hair getting bigger each week? I love it.
Paula is such a phoney, I wish she'd just be honest
Bo- Dude, I tried, I swear, but this guy does NOTHING for me. Nada, zip, zilch, nothing!
Aww Paula's sharing her drugs with Randy now, how sweet.I agree with Simon.
Anwar- Oh Anwar I hate this song, so very much but I still like you. He sounded good, it's so hard to tell though because my hate for that song is so strong.
When Paula speaks I hear that voice they used for the Charlie Brown grown ups
Anthony 1985? Man I feel old. I know he's just not the best & we're supposed to vote on voice only but I'm a giant sucker for this kid, I just like him.
Vonzell- Hee hee a Footloose song. Ouch this is so Six Flags and I usually like her.
Appartenly the judges heard something else, I'm confused.
Scott- The low notes were terrible but the chorus part was really good. Weird. Needs to stop back talking Simon ASAP.
Dh just said Scott's singing to Paula....She's gone, she's gone...what went wrong.....bawhahaha!
Carrie- Carrie turned into Kelly Clarkson, she looks like her tonight. I thought it was a weak performance, it didn't work for me.
William Hung is in the commercial-Ha!
Constantine- This is crazy, he sounds awesome! I had to rewind it and watch it again. Best of the night by far! Wow.
Is Ryan really that short or is Constantine really tall?

Gone Nadia?
Best Constantine by far!

 

[StaceyA]

BTW, I thought Paula was going to jump right out of her shirt when Simon gave Constantine the thumbs-up!

Ditto, it looked like she grabbed her pants cause they almost fell off....LOL

She also had to grab onto the table cause she almost fell when going to sit back in her chair....she is really getting bad!

 

[jimmalru80]

Freddie is nearly impossible to recreate. I found myself comparing him to F.M. and I just did not hear it.

 

[disneyworldgirl]

My top three tonight-- Anthony, Constantine, and Carrie.

Bottom three-- Scott, Vonzell, and Bo (much as it pains me to say it).

 

[damo]

Thought they all finished quite well. Didn't especially like Constantine. He was off on too many notes. He sure sold it well though. I don't think anyone should be singing that song.

I think Nadia will be gone.

 

[Nancy]

What did Scott say to Simon??? A few of us here missed it.

 

[6_Time_Momma]

You know, before when you guys would say stuff about Paula, I wasn't seeing it, but man!! Tonight I was so embarrassed for her!!!! Almost like when Farrah Fawcett appeared on that late night talk show!

Wow!!

I agree....never a good choice to do a Freddie Mercury song.....EVERYONE pales in comparison!

 

[StaceyA]

You know, before when you guys would say stuff about Paula, I wasn't seeing it, but man!! Tonight I was so embarrassed for her!!!! Almost like when Farrah Fawcett appeared on that late night talk show!

Wow!!

 

[Nancy]

Top 3 tonight for me.
Carrie
Anthony
Bo

Bottom 3
Anwar
Scott
Constantine

Who goes home? probably Scott.

 

[geetey]

Palmtreegirl
I love your recaps! I think Constantine is a giant! Hahahhaha Okay - I have heard that Ryan Seacrest isn't very tall either.
I thought Constantine did great with his song. I still think he is smary, but he is doing really well.

 

[tae1218]

can we vote off one of the judges?

My DD7 asked me if we could vote off Paula. I wish we could.

Constantine was our favorite tonight but she has a soft spot for Anthony.