Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

[Sandy22]

Lucky you, you get to watch it on TV. I am watching a internet feed from Italy. Since I speak NO Italian I have no idea what they are saying (or who these folks are right now LOL!)

You can't pick up the CBC programming? (Canadian Broadcasting Corporation)

 

[Sandy22]

I didn't enjoy Scott as much as Randy seemed to!

 

[CarolA]

You can't pick up the CBC programming? (Canadian Broadcasting Corporation)

Not in Nashville, TN! LOL!

 

[disneyworldgirl]

Carrie's "When Will I Be Loved?" was okay, but I've heard her do alot better. Again, another potentially powerful voice, but the vocals were lacking.

Nikko's back! And he wants you back! Vocally very strong, showed alot of energy, and seemed to connect with the audience. One of the best of the night.

 

[Disney1fan2002]

Simon should of been nicer to Nikko! GAWD, he was just flown in Tuesday morning, so he did not have the week of preparation the other 11 contestsnats have had. GEESH< cut the kid a break, he sounded good!

 

[Sandy22]

I think Mikayla, Lyndsey, Scott, Anthony will be at the bottom this week.

Yikes - gotta go switch Official threads - Amazing Race is on!

 

[damo]

Lindsay or Mikalah should be gone. Constantine was actually good tonight!

 

[RyMickey]

I don't know...I kinda liked Carrie. I agree with Simon that she knows what she can sing and she does it well.

Anyway, now that it's done:

Top: Nadia, Bo, Carrie, Scott (a surprise)
Bottom: Lindsay, Jessica, Mikalah
Going Home: Lindsay - Has she really sung good at all yet? I keep hearing the judges say they love her low range, but she hasn't shown it at all.

Just my thoughts.

RyMickey

 

[J.Cooper]

Nikko wasn't bad as Simon said. Nikko did better than some of the others. Simon is losing it! I agree Mikalah or Lindsey may get the boot. I'm afraid Anthony could possibly be in the bottom 2 also.

 

[IloveDMB]

I think Constantine did awesome tonight. He finally found a song that suited him well.

Lindsey has got to go. I have no idea how she made it this far. Her performance was boring, flat, and just bad.

I'm glad Nikko is back. I liked his performance and he is a good performer. He deserved to be here over Lindsey, if it wasn't 6 and 6.

 

[PrincessaC]

Okay I watched the show tonight.. but I can't remember the numbers or orders...will someone plse list them so I can vote... TIA

 

[disneyworldgirl]

Okay, now to put my neck in the noose and list my picks, based solely upon their performances tonight. Here they are in order from the bottom up:

12th Place-- Mykalah
11th Place-- Anwar
10th Place-- Lindsay
9th Place-- Vonzell
8th Place-- Carrie
7th Place-- Jessica
6th Place-- Constantine
5th Place-- Anthony
4th Place-- Nikko
3rd Place-- Scott
2nd Place-- Nadia

And tonight's winner is (drumroll, please)... Bo!

 

[PrincessaC]

Okay, now to put my neck in the noose and list my picks, based solely upon their performances tonight. Here they are in order from the bottom up:

12th Place-- Mykalah
11th Place-- Anwar
10th Place-- Lindsay
9th Place-- Vonzell
8th Place-- Carrie
7th Place-- Jessica
6th Place-- Constantine
5th Place-- Anthony
4th Place-- Nikko
3rd Place-- Scott
2nd Place-- Nadia

And tonight's winner is (drumroll, please)... Bo!

He was great tonight! I have to help Nikko out though. I thought he was good.

 

[Jilliebean]

Loved Bo tonight!

Bye Bye Mikalah (I hope!)

 

[Emme]

OK I am a 40 year old married woman with a crush on Bo Can't help it, the guy is awesome!

Mikaleh really has to go! There is just something nail bitingly awful about her!

Emmy

 

[palmtreegirl]

Whoa weak night......

Jessica- Eh she's OK, but there's something I just don't like about her.
Anwar- I was so disappointed with him.
Mikayla- wow that was terrible.
Constantine- Best performance he's had, it was pretty good.
Lindsay- Didn't think she was as bad as they said but not that good either.
Anthony- Boring but I thought he sounded pretty good.
Nadia- FINALLY a great performance, blew everyone else away.
Bo- Still don't like the guy, sorry I tried.
Vonzell- Thought she was pretty good tonight. Looked like she was in the talent portion of Miss America with the dress though.
Scott- Sounded better, maybe it was because everyone else was so bad.
Carrie- I just didn't buy her singing that song, it's like when she sang the Janis Joplin song. Needs to pick a lighter, young song.
Nikko I enjoyed his performance despite it sounded off in some spots.

Best- Nadia, Nadia and Nadia.
Worst-Mikayla should go home.

 

[elgerber]

I love Nikko, I was so glad to hear he's back, and I thought he did great. I really could have done without the jeans though.

Mikayla was just awful, why is she here????????? And she looked like a hooker, I really have a HUGE problem with a 16 year old dressing that way, especially on national television.

I really didn't want to like Bo when this first started, but he has really grown on me. That thing on his chest was weird and a little creepy though.

I have liked Anwar somewhat, but didn't like him tonight. Tamyra sang that same song in season 1 and made Paula cry (good cry LOL), this wasn't even close.

Ain't too proud to beg is one of my all time favorites, and while Scott was good, it wasn't quite good enough for me. I think George Huff did a way better job last year with it.

Poor Anthony, that was so dull!!!!!!!!!! Why doesn't anyone sing Breakin Up is Hard to do, the way it was originally recorded instead of that 80's Ballad version????

 

[mouseclick1]

Here's my take on tonight:

First Girl(I still don't even know her name!) - She does abolutely nothing for me. She could stay or go and I probably wouldn't even notice.

Anwar - Usually love him; thought he did only so-so tonight.

Constantine - Usually make fun of him but actually liked him tonight!

Lindsay - Did not impress me; one of the worst performances of the evening.

Mikayla - "Son of a Preacher Man" is one of my favorite songs and she killed it.

Bo - He's been one of my favorites from the start and still is!

Nadia - Another favorite who was awesome tonight!

Scott - Thought he did OK; he actually looked bored for a while but he sounded good.

Anthony - I thought he did better than the judges did. He's not one of my favorites but he was OK tonight, though I don't think he'll last too long.

Carrie - I thought she sounded good but needed to work the stage a little more. Country really isn't my thing.

Vonzel (SP?)- She's a good singer and seems to have a good personality, but nothing has really clicked for me yet when she sings.

Nikko - I am so glad he is in the top 12. I actually liked him better than Mario! He was a lot of fun to watch tonight!

My top two favorites right now are Bo and Nadia!

 

[Tina]

What number was Bo tonight? I thought it was 8, but now I'm not sure. Anyone remember?

 

[disneyworldgirl]

Okay I watched the show tonight.. but I can't remember the numbers or orders...will someone plse list them so I can vote... TIA

Hi, PrincessaC! Here are the phone #'s you needed:

Jessica-- 1-866-IDOLS-01
Anwar-- 1-866-IDOLS-02
Mykalah-- 1-866-IDOLS-03
Constantine-- 1-866-IDOLS-04
Lindsay-- 1-866-IDOLS-05
Anthony-- 1-866-IDOLS-06
Nadia-- 1-866-IDOLS-07
Bo-- 1-866-IDOLS-08
Vonzell-- 1-866-IDOLS-09
Scott-- 1-866-IDOLS-10
Carrie-- 1-866-IDOLS-11
Nikko-- 1-866-IDOLS-12

Now to vote for our faves and sweat it out until the results show tomorrow!