Would you do it again or would you just attend the party if you had the opportunity
I would do it again. Here's why:
Food is important to me. I'm on a very restricted diet due to health issues, at Disney I ignore that. I don't want to get stuck eating whatever food I find. Why waste a "cheat" meal on cold fries?
I can't handle long periods of crazy heat (see medical issues) so a TS meal guarantees me a spot to sit, in air-conditioning. Without that I wouldn't get as much joy out of the rest of the party.
We've been to a party before, and know that we aren't missing anything we *love*. We're not interested in character photos (except for ghosts) or the Sanderson Sisters stage show. Why not have a great meal, which is something we do love, with that time?
The food at the TS places feels like part of the celebration. A coffin cake at dessert, a festive drink, little details like that add to the experience for me. A hot dog bolted down while racing to get to the next line does not feel special.
But, YMMV, I know lots of people that think "wasting" party time on TS is crazy. You get 8 hours (from 4pm to 12am) for me spending 25% of it being served great food is joy not a waste. I've got BoG (first time ever, so excited) and Tony's Town Square for MNSSHP, and the Garden View Tea Room followed by LTT for the Christmas party.
