Offical American Idol Discussion Thread

[Kimberle]

I remember Simon doing the "finger thing" during last years AI, too.

 

[FOJMO]

Originally posted by ShuisFan584
If they wanted to change anything, they should just make it so that you can only have one vote per phoneline.

I TOTALLY AGREE. I have even seen some posters here on the DISboards say they voted numerous times for one person and IMHO, that's hardly fair. They should limit the amount of votes to one per phone line.

And, also a comment about Kim's song last night -- she sang it just fine, but the song itself was so lame! It sounded like something that was written by an elementary school kid...

 

[damo]

Anyone else think it's cute the way George says mush-tash?

 

[calypso*a*go-go]

I think it's cute too and I definitely prefer him without the cookie duster.

 

[musicalSaranader]

Hehe, cookie duster. I've never heard that term for a "mushtash" before, but it's cute!

 

[pjlla]

I thought I had mis-heard him when I heard "mush-tash"! Too funny!................P

 

[FOJMO]

I didn't think anyone could be worse than Camile, but John Stevens just topped her!

He was HORRIBLE! Terribly off-key and boring. The two of them will certainly be in the bottom three this week!

 

[Poohbear123]

Finally, Jasmine brought down the house!

 

[damo]

Does anyone else find that the vocals are way too quiet? The band is supposed to play under the vocals but the vocals are way under the band tonight. It is way off balance!

 

[Poohbear123]

Yes, it is the band is way too loud!

 

[Mickey's sunshine]

yep, band definately too loud - they need to be playing behind the audience. Fantasia did good but I still DO NOT like her!!!

 

[Poohbear123]

I think John Stevens is OUT and they will keep Camille!

 

[damo]

I think it is down to JPL, Camile and John Stevens. You had to have a really big voice to come across well tonight. Even La Toya had trouble being heard.

 

[musicalSaranader]

Oh Johnny, you were weak tonight. I was disappointed. You need to smile more, and loosen up! You have so much potential, you need to let it all out!

My favorites tonight were LaToya and George. Normally George is not among my favorites because of that rasp in his voice, but he was definitely the best tonight.

 

[Mickey's sunshine]

I agree on George, not one of my favorites but he did good tonight!!! I say give John Stevens a couple of years and he will be more ready for this type of competition.

 

[chelsea&austinsmom]

I thought George and Jasmine were both great tonight. I just don't see why they like Fantasia I just don't like her voice.

 

[Tinkbell]

I thought Jasmine, Fantasia and George were the best tonight. How could Randy call Diana the best of the night? I thought she was so cheesy.

 

[grinningghost]

As much as I dislike her personality, I thought Fantasia was the best tonight.

 

[Nancy]

My bottom 3 are John S. JPL and Camille. As much as I would like JS to stay in (because he is from here) I think he's getting way over his head and he'll probably be gone. He really looked and sounded nervous tonight.

My favs tonight...Jasmine and George. LaToya was missing something tonight, Jennifer was back to making faces while she sang, Amy...I'm not sure what I feel about her, pretty much indifferent on her performance; Diana..I like her and her singing, but she is just too polished for a 16 year old...what a difference between her and John S. Fantasia, I just don't like her and I have a hard time watching her. I don't see why everyone likes her.

 

[Karel]

I'm really sad about John Stevens. He seems like such a nice clean cut kid, very real and sweet but he needs to loosen up. I hope he can hold on this week and come out next week swinging - but I'm afraid it may be the end of the road.

I thought Jennifer was pretty good tonight but when it's all over, LaToya, Fantasia and Jasmine will be the top three at show's end.