Hi beaglefan. My family did successfully do the Comfort Inn / Atlantis plan.
Here are some key pointers
1) Make sure when you calculate the total cost, you include the taxes and the per person charge. If you look at the bottom of the Choice Hotel page where you "Book Room", it says... * These rates do not include taxes of 20.00% or other charges of 20.95 PER PERSON PER DAY*
It is still a good deal but can get confusing
2) Do not take a boat taxi over to Atlantis. It is a LONG walk from the dock to the Comfort Suites AND it only runs at certain times making it hard to catch boat on your return. I would look up what they charge for the boat taxi, then negotiate that same rate with taxi drive who will take you straight to Comfort Suites.
3) When you get to Comfort Suites it is absolutely simple. You simply go to desk and say you are checking in and out right now. Get you receipt, your wristbands, and then it's a fairly short walk over to Atlantis
<<<EDIT>> Real Price breakdown for those considering the Comfort Suites method for Atlantis Tickets
When booking this Comfort Suite, there are certainrates that are not quoted into your reservation. IN fact, you will have to pay cash for them when you arrive, so even though you paid in advance, you still owe more. Here is how it works
$223.20 -- 1 BR King bed w/sleeper for 4 people
$86.54 -- estimated taxes
$83.80 -- $20.95 X 4 people for energy and houesekeeping
$80.00 -- 3rd & 4th person in room charge (you may not have to pay this since I believe "kids stay free")
$473.54 -- Grand Total for 2 adults & 2 kids
... The website says this Energy surcharge: 15.95 per person per night. Housekeeping gratuities: 5.00 per person per night These are additional charges not included in nightly estimated total and must be paid directly at the hotel. Persons 16 and older are charged as adults. 3rd/4th person charged 40.00 per night + tax and service charges.
so you also need to add on $20.95 per person and then another $40 per person for the 3rd & 4th person on your reservation
I am not sure what the rate is on Aquaventure now, but my understanding is they have gotten cheaper, so not sure how much you would save by doing Comfort Suites anymore... used to be a good deal, not so sure anymore
Now I have a question for you?
We are going to be driving to the port from New Mexico and spending the night. Do you have any recommendations on what hotel to stay at night before that would offer Park & Sail for our car?
Thanks!!