Not-so-Magic Kingdom

The article that the OP referred to has a lot of in-accuracies in it. Basically, the writer of the article took a petition started by a mother of an autistic child as as completely accurate when it has a lot of mis-stated, so-called "facts". Disney did get rid of the Special Assistance Pass at Disneyland, but they are in the process of replacing it with a Special Assistance Card. There is no evidence that they did or meant to get rid of assistance that people with autism need in order to go to the parks. Here's a link to the discussion we've been having on this subject on the disABILITIES Board.
The change is being made to Disneyland and doesn't affect WDW. It appears that they are trying to change the way things are being done at DL to be more like what is done at WDW. The system was changed at WDW about 4-5 years ago and there was a learning period while the system bugs were worked out. Things are not perfect at WDW, but in general, it works well.

One important difference between the 2 parks though is that many of the lines in DL are not wheelchair accessible, while most (and all the fastpass lines) at WDW are accessible.
In general, at WDW, people with wheelchairs or ecvs wait in the same line with everyone else. These are called "Mainstream Queues/Lines". All of the lines at AK and the Studio were built as Mainstream Lines. Lines at MK and Epcot have been renovated to be Mainstream as much as possible. There are a few lines that could not be changed (Spaceship Earth and Small World come to mind) where people in wheelchairs or ecvs go directly to the exit to board. In most cases though, if wheelchair or ecv users board at the exit, it's after waiting in the mainstream line and being "detoured" just before the rest of the line gets to boarding. We frequently see the people who were just ahead of us in line getting off at Buzz Lightyear, for example, while we are still waiting at the exit to board. Because there is little "advantage" to renting a wheelchair at WDW (other than having a place to sit while you wait) there is not much incentive at WDW to rent a wheelchair or ecv if you don't actually need one.

From what I have read, at DL, they were basically giving a pass to anyone who came to Guest Services and asked for (or in some cases, demanded) one. Everyone got the same type of pass/access, whether it was someone who could walk, but not climb stairs or a family with a child with autism. They are changing from that to a "what does the guest need" system.
At WDW (and since the change at DL too), you have to be able to explain your need to Guest Services. If a Guest Assistance Card is given out, it has a stamp to tell what assistance is needed, such as, use an entrance without stairs if you can't climb stairs; a quieter place to wait for someone with autism or similar problems; a place to wait out of the sun if a medical condition makes being in the sun a problem. If (for example) you say you can't stand in line because of a leg or endurance problem, it will be suggested that you rent a wheelchair or ecv and use fastpass as much as possible.
QUOTE FROM WDW GUIDEBOOK FOR GUESTS WITH DISABILITIES:Some Guests may be concerned that they do not have the stamina to wait in our queues. We strongly suggest these Guests consider using a wheelchair, personal scooter or Electric Convenience Vehicle (ECV), as the distance between our attractions is much greater than the length of our queues.
Here's a link to the Guests with Disabilities page on the official Disney website. Some of the people who have been told that are very vocal about their displeasure with that.
At DL, they were also giving passes for a diagnosis rather than on what assistance the person with that diagnosis needed. So someone at DL might have gotten a pass because they had Cerebral Palsy (CP) or Multiple Sclerosis (MS)and walked well, but with slight limp. Compare that to WDW, where someone with CP would be asked what needs they have. Depending on their disability and needs, they may or may not get a pass. For example, 4 young ladies in my DD's wheelchair dance group, all have CP and use power wheelchairs, but 2 would be able to use the Mainstream lines and would not be likely to get a Guest Assistance Card at WDW. Of the other 2, one is multiply disabled, including attention deficit problems and obsessive compulsive behavior that makes being confined in a line very difficult. The other one drives her power wheelchair with a head control and would have a hard time manouvering thru the turns and switchbacks of some of the mainstream lines.
At WDW, the Guest Assistance Card is issued to the person with a disability and can be used by him/her and up to 5 members of their party. But, it can only be used for a ride when the person with a disability is going on the ride. I've read complaints that at DL, the passes were sometimes used for groups of up to 25 people and "Grandma" might be sitting waiting while the rest of her party used the pass to go on Space Mountain.
 
As the father of a disabled son and the son of a disabled mother, I can only applaud Disney for rectifying this situation. I have long been appalled by the abuse of the system by people who clearly had no need for any special priviledge. I am also sure that those with real need for this type of special dispensation will still receive the kind of service we have come to expect of Disney. I have visited DLP on two occassions and they already operate this type of system in the parks with no issues. The only people who should be upset are those who abused the system and forced the change in the first place!::MickeyMo :jumping1:
 
Kath816, you needn't sound so hostile about waiting for DennisP's "rebuttal". His whole point was that while he objects to blantant abuse of FOTL requests (we have seen this all too often in WDW when wheelchairs are rented and the parties using them change frequently, etc. so they get FOTL access), he also objected to the tone of the editorial that seemed to say that people who really needed the access were being denied. i.e. the child with autism mentioned in the article. I have occasionally required a wheelchair due to injury while at WDW and felt ridiculously guilty when offered FOTL access and often left the wheelchair outside of the attraction and used a cane to get on the ride. People who need help should get help - people who really don't should thank God they don't and walk on the ride unassisted. (again, I recognize that disabilities are not readily visible and I mean people who really, really need help whether you and I can see it or not!!!!).
 
People with wheelchairs or ecvs don't get FOTL access at any of the WDW parks, unless they are on a Make A WISH (or similar program) trip. In the past (like pre 1998-99) wheelchair users did get FOL treatment for many rides because the regular lines were not wheelchair accessible and it was easier for the CMs to control traffic that way - NOT to give a perk to wheelchair users.

AK and the Studio were built so that all lines are wheelchair accessible and people with wheelchairs or ecvs wait in line with everyone else.
At MK and Epcot, it was not possible to make all lines on older rides wheelchair accessible, but all of the FastPass lines and as many of the other lines as could be made wheelchair accessible are.
 

This is in response to Bob o. I will give you the benfit of the doubt that you do not know anyone that has autism, if you had then you would have not made the comments you made. I have a son that is seven and has Autism, these children do not cope well in crowds and they panic in turn results in a tanturm to what most people would call a bratty child, this is usually the only way they can cope with there feelings, they do not think as we do. I do agree that the pass is abused, I also think that you should have a doctors note in order to get the pass. Why would you think that it is fair for a child with autism not to visit Disney, do you think that we should stay locked up at home and out of the public eye, I don't think so children with Autism are just like other kids and love disney they should not be cheated out of the magic just because they cannot stand in lines very long, and if you think that this is unfair then maybe you and everyone else that feels the way you do should have a child with autism and maybe you would view life a little differently.

And to the people who think that the wheelchairs are being abused, I am a healthy person and it still wore me out to walk all of these parks everyday, some people have things wrong with them and they can't walk that far for that long, I guess they should not go to disney either right? I think disney should be seen by everyone big , small, or disabled, this place is suppose to be magical, I can't belive some of things you people have said about abusing the guest assistance pass. Be thankful for your health because it could happen to you.:mad: :mad:
 
I think my message was misunderstood. As the daughter of a dad with a serious heart condition (which could not be "observed" by anyone) and the aunt of a niece with CP it is upsetting ONLY to see people abuse the system. Everyone who needs to gain admission to attractions more easily and quickly absolutely should have access to the medical considerations provided by Disney. As an example, on our last trip, we witnessed a family taking turns in a wheelchair, actually jumping on top of each other, and in and out of it laughing and foooling around. I remember thinking that I hoped someone who really needed assistance was not denied a wheelchair because of this family. But that also lead me to realize why Disney made the decision to check medical conditions more carefully. Hope this clarifies and no one was insulted -- that was not the intent.
 
WDW has Mainstream Acess for most rides/attactions, which means people in wheelchairs or ecvs wait in the regular (Mainstream) line. Here's a list of things with Mainstream access copied from the official Disney site's page for guests with mobility disabilities:
Attractions providing mainstream queue access include:

Magic Kingdom® Park
  • Ariel's Grotto
  • Astro Orbiter
  • Buzz Lightyear's Space Ranger Spin
  • Donald's Boat
  • Fantasyland® Character Festival
  • Judge's Tent
  • Mickey's Country House
  • Mickey's PhilharMagic
  • Mike Fink Keelboats (seasonal)
  • Minnie's Country House
  • Pirates of the Caribbean
  • Space Mountain®
  • Splash Mountain®
  • The Barnstormer at Goofy's Wiseacres Farm
  • "The Enchanted Tiki Room Under New Management"
  • The ExtraTERRORestrial Alien Encounter
  • The Hall of Presidents
  • The Magic Carpets of Aladdin
  • The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh
  • The Timekeeper (seasonal)
  • Tomorrowland® Indy Speedway
  • Toontown Hall of Fame
  • Walt Disney's Carousel of Progress (seasonal)

    Epcot®
  • FUTURE WORLD
  • Imagination!
  • Innoventions East
  • Innoventions West
  • Mission: SPACE
  • Test Track
  • The Living Seas
  • Universe of Energy
  • Wonders of Life: All Attractions
  • WORLD SHOWCASE
  • China Pavilion: "Wonders of China"
  • France Pavilion: "Impressions de France"
  • FriendShip Boats
  • Norway Pavilion: Maelstrom
  • The American Adventure Pavilion: "The American Adventure"


    Disney-MGM Studios
  • Disney-MGM Studios Backlot Tour
  • Fantasmic!
  • Jim Henson's Muppet*Vision 3D
  • Playhouse Disney - Live On Stage!
  • Rock 'n' Roller Coaster® Starring Aerosmith
  • Sounds Dangerous - Starring Drew Carey
  • Star Tours
  • The Great Movie Ride
  • The Magic of Disney Animation
  • "The Twilight Zone Tower of Terror™"
  • _Voyage of the Little Mermaid
  • Walt Disney: One Man's Dream
  • Who Wants To Be A Millionaire - Play It!

    Disney's Animal Kingdom® Theme Park
  • Caravan Stage
  • DINOSAUR
  • Grandmother Willow's Grove
  • It's Tough To Be A Bug
  • Kali River Rapids
  • Kilimanjaro Safaris
  • Lion King Theater
  • Maharajah Jungle Trek
  • Primeval Whirl
  • Theater in the Wild
  • The Boneyard
  • TriceraTop Spin

    For many rides that don't have Mainstream Access, wheelchair users wait in line with everyone else and then are detoured to the exit for boarding just before the regular line gets to the boarding area (Haunted Mansion is an example of this).
    There are a few rides where there is no way to make the entrance wheelchair accessible, so people using wheelchairs board at the exit without being in the usual line. One example of this is El Rio del Tiempo in Mexico (where there is seldom a line, but there will be a wait for the wheelchair accessible boat to come around). Another example is Small World. Spaceship Earth also has wheelchair users (and people with special needs) board at the exit. There is a little lounge type area set up there for waiting. We have always had a wait there of 15-20 minutes (we usually go when the standby line is basically walking right on).
    So, someone renting a wheelchair because they think it will provide them faster access (ot FOTL access) will find that for most rides, they will be waiting in the same line as everyone else. In many cases, you actually wait longer because there are fire an evacuation codes regarding how many special needs people are allowed to be inside an attraction at a time.
 
Kath 816, sorry if i misunderstood you!!!! Again, the whole point was just how wrong The New Tribune was in printing their editorial withou getting the correct information. EVERYONE should be able to see and enjoy the parks as comfortably as possible!!!!
 
This topic is VERY near and dear to my heart, as I am the proud mom of an 11 year old boy with Autism. As stated earlier, many of you feel that the passes are abused by people that have no OBVIOUS disability. I agree that there may be abuse of the passes, however, bear in mind that not ALL disabilities are obvious. To look at my son, you would never ina million years know that he has Autism. To us, the Special Access is a Godsend. It allows us to share in a 'normal' experience with him.
I have had perfect strangers tell me that my son 'needs a good slapping' when he has meltdowns in public because we've had to wait in line, or he becomes over-stimulated. HOW DARE THEY!!!! As far as I am concerned, when we visit the parks, it is with the intent of "Checking our troubles at the gate". While we are there with our son, it is truly magical because just for that short while, its as if we aren't judged, and the goal of all the people at the parks is to have a wonderful day creating magical memories.
Just as I would not judge the validity of someone elses need for Special Access, I ask that you not be so quick to judge others based on appearances only. There very often is more beneath the surface. And as far as I'm concerned, I think the Disney parks should be the last place ANYONE should be judged.
{And now I shall climb off of my soapbox ;) }
 
To Disneyana, thank you, what you said is so true, I also have a seven year old with Autism and to have been judged as if he is just a brat, I guess until you live in our shoes you can't see life as we see it through our childrens eyes. Thanks
 
Magic Kingdom Park:

It is my pleasure to speak up on behalf of my Autistic child. I'm glad that what I said was read with an open mind, and I hope that I haven't offended anyone with my comments. I just get so frustrated when I try to do something as normal--and mundane--as shop for groceries and people will stare at my son sitting in the 'merchandise' part of the cart and wonder aloud why that big kid is riding in there? Or stare at us when I demonstrate how words are pronounced, or ask him what color the bananas are. I admit I used to be quick to judge when a child would act up at the store. Now, I look at the parents and the child and say "How lucky you are that you can pitch a fit right here! I only wish I was able to vent my frustrations so easily" and both the kids and parents will look at me--the kids, because someone validated their feelings, and the parents for the understanding that their child is not just being naughty for the sake of being naughty.

Once again, I step down from the soapbox.
{Can you tell that this is a topic about which I am very passionate!?!}
 
There are 2 errors that I am aware of on the allearsnet page. One of them is the name of the card; it is called the Special Assistance Card at Disneyland (an update of the Special Assistance Pass). At WDW, it is called the Guest Assistance Card (previous to 1999, it was called a Guest Assistance Pass at WDW). The change from "pass" to "card" was made to better reflect what it is. It is not a pass and does not give immediate access, but is a tool to let CMs know what sorts of assistance guests need.
The other is that although many people do bring a doctor's letter, it is not required.
There are many good hints for people dealing with autism on that site and also on this site, plus, you can always visit the disABILITIES Board to ask questions.
 
I think we all know there as been abuse of the Guest Assistance Card, so I agree, Disney should be more strict in thier policy and require documentation.

I also think many people fail to realize that not all disabilities are visible. Ask yourself how many times comments have been made when someone gets out a wheelchair and walks normally, far too many times.

I myself have a form of MS called Myasthenia Gravis, I can walk around and even run at times, I appear to perfectly healthy. I never use a wheelchair or have problems doing any daily task.
Of course it takes 15 to 22 pills a day to allow me to function without assistance.

WDW is another story, I just recently returned from a five day stay and found it extremely difficult to make it through the day without approaching overdoses of my medication. I found myself taking many rest and exhausted by early evening. As I told my wife, I do believe for my own health it may be best to use a wheelchair if we go again. Of course I suspect I'll get stares and comments which I don't deserve. I'm not looking to get to the front of the line, and I'll gladly wait but still some will say I'm abusing the system even though I have documentation.

The point is its very hard for the avg. person to distinguish who is and who isn't disabled and therefore have a need. So its best to leave it up to the doctors and Disney policy, rather than to accuse anyone of abuse.

Be happy your heathly!
 
DisneyAnna, Magic Kingdom Park, and everyone else that has an autistic child, well said!
My autistic child is only 3, but I already see the judgements from others every day. They look at my child and wonder why he is just cooing like a baby instead of talking and someone always makes a comment when he has a tantrum in public.
When that other poster commented on we shouldn't have our children in the parks I actually cried. That is the kind of discrimination that I know my child will have to have his whole life. My 7 year old is already more sensitive to my son than most adults I encounter
Now, I have two other children. Am I suppose to take those two to Disney and leave my autistic one at home? As most autistic parents know it is already hard to lead a normal life and do normal things like go to the mall or go out to eat or take your kids to Chuck e Cheese or bowling. Autistic kids simply can get sensory overload and cannot handle normal situations. Even with the special needs pass we still can't sit through any shows because my son has a limit of about 10 mins he can sit still in my lap.
That special needs pass is an absolute must for my family to go. If my child would stand in line without getting overloaded and screaming, we would do it. He simply can't. Does that mean he shouldn't have the experience of Disney? My son doesn't show alot of emotions, but when I see him smiling on a ride and I can actually tell what is going on in his head even for just a moment, it makes going worthwhile.
If you don't think we should have special access to the attraction, then you are just ignorant.
 
I just returned from a trip to Disney. My daughter-in-law had trouble walking the long distances by the third day and I had some knee problems. We rented a wheelchair and shared it between us to take breaks from the walking and standing. I really don't understand why it should matter to anyone that we did this. At each attraction, we left the wheelchair in the stroller parking area and waited in the regular line with everyone else. I believe that Disney makes strollers/wheelchairs/ECVs available to all who might want that assistance. It has nothing to do with special front of the line priviledges.

Sondra :earsgirl:
 
This thread is getting heated because many people feel that *they* have some special circumstance that makes it so that *they* should be treated differently from everyone else. If it were truly the case that there were this many people in the world who deserved to go ahead of me, I'd never get anywhere, and neither would any of your children because they too would be in line behind someone who had better "special circumstances".

Disney is right to tighten the reigns here. They need to think of all of their guests, not just those with whatever disability has been presented. The fact that your child can't wait in line does not trump my child's right to have a turn. What Bob O. said was right. Visit during the off season when crowds are low if your child cannot wait and is over-stimulated by large crowds. No one is faulting a child who is disabled. No one is saying that they should be locked in their rooms, so let's get back to reality. What people are saying, legitimately, is that the fact that your child needs some sort of special acommodation does not mean that everyone else must get out of the way.

To the poster who questions "fairness". Please! Life is not fair! Their are children who go to bed hungry every night in this country. To them Disney is not a right - it's not even a dream. Don't speak of "fair" when it comes to whether or not your child can handle a line. When your family can afford to drop thousands of $$$ for a week in WDW while another family can't afford to heat their home or feed themselves, talking about "fair" is more than a little outlandish. Let's get some perspective on the matter, please.

Erin :D
 
Hmmmmm....let me see if I understand.
You are saying that because I have a special needs child, they should not be afforded any special courtesies to adapt the experience for them--is that right?
So, in essence, you would also say that the policy of providing the option of hearing a voice mail message in English or Spanish is unnecessary, correct?
Now, I am not saying that the inability to speak fluent English is a handicap, I am just trying to understand that you feel no type of accomodations should be made to adapt a given situation to a larger population--is that correct?
A long time ago, I saw a bumpersticker on a car parking in a handicapped spot at the mall. It was a VERY cold day, and as luck would have it, I had to park quite a distance from the entrance. As I walked, I TOTALLY begrudged all of the lucky folks who got to park closer than me. The bumper sticker read: "I would gladly trade my parking spot for two good legs."
THAT totally shamed me!! And I honestly think that that was the point that I stopped judging others without knowing their circumstances.
I guess what I'm getting at is that., while it may be frustrating to have to stand in lines on a hot day with your kids whining and crabbing, please understand that I would GLADLY give up my Special Access Pass to have my son attend 'regular' school, go to birthday parties, have friends come over to play, see him play baseball, hear him say to me "Mommy, I love you so much!"


Think about it.......then if you wish to begrudge me the Special Access Pass, so be it.
 
You are saying that because I have a special needs child, they should not be afforded any special courtesies to adapt the experience for them--is that right?

EXACTLY!!! They're not being afforded special "courtesies", they're being given special privileges. There is a HUGE difference. And no, the experience is the experience. Each individual adapts it to themselves. I am truly sorry that your child cannot stand on a line. I am quite sure that this makes life difficult for you. And I agree that going to the grocery store is going to be hard for you. However, Disney is a choice - not a right. If your child can't stand on line, how do they handle the crowds inherent to a Disney vacation? How do you get your food? How do they deal with needing to use the restroom if there is a line? Do you just move ahead? Does my daughter's need to use the toilet become less important because of your child? Does my daughter not need her lunch as quickly? Does my daughter not count as much as your child? Apparently you think so. The fact that your child has a disability that makes crowds and lines more difficult does not mean that everyone else in the world should move out of your way.

So, in essence, you would also say that the policy of providing the option of hearing a voice mail message in English or Spanish is unnecessary, correct?

This is simply ridiculous. This has no impact on the enjoyment of other guests. You choose, English or Spanish. However, when a group simply walks to the front of the line while others have been waiting however long, and have no opportunity to access the same privelege (ie, fast pass), you are impacting everyone around you.

You have decided that your child's disability matters more than everyone else. I wonder, would you support Disney allowing everyone in a wheelchair front of the line access? I mean, they have a disability and life is arguably harder for them. Shouldn't they be given special priveleges? What if that means that you arrive at a ride and there is a ten minute wait even with your special access card because, well, someone else is in front of you? How would your child handle this situation? Would they have a meltdown? Would you have to leave the parks for the day? Would you be annoyed because you had to wait? What about parents of toddlers? Talk about those prone to meltdown! Shouldn't they get special priveleges because their children can't handle waiting in line? Are those children less important than yours?

I am certain that you would move heaven and earth for a "normal" child as opposed to a child with a disability. I don't doubt that for a minute. But please don't suppose that therefore all of the other parents out there need to stop whatever they are doing and let you go about your way. It just doesn't work like that.

Clearly there are times when someone should be automatically bumped to the front of the line. Make a Wish has been pointed out several times. There is, however, a difference between a terminal child and one with an emotional/developmental disability.

Erin :D
 
I in no way intended for nay of my statements to be interpreted to mean that because my child has 'special needs' that makes him more important and should be given the red carpet treatment. I apologize if there was any misunderstanding. However, I think it should be reiterated that just because you have the Special Access Card, it does neot mean that you are simply ushered right onto the ride/attraction.
Quite often, we have still had to wait. What the card does for us is eliminate the often over-stimulation of the queue line. Many of them have television monitors or music which, in addition to the crowds is simply a melt down in the making.
With regard to your youngster unable to avoid the meltdowns, please understand that I know that is a difficult situation, but my son is 11, and looks every bit his age. When HE has a meltdown, we have had to endure stares, glares and rude remarks further adding to our embarassment.
As for toileting issues, I simply take him in with me if my husband is occupied with our daughter. Talk about rude stares, but since he can't tell me if someone is touching him inappropriately, I gladly suffer through the stares and judgements.

I think we all agree that there are folks who are abusing the priviledge--and it IS a priveledge--and that is unfortunate.
I don't know what how to avoid the abuse, but I certainly don't think eliminating the Special Access Cards is the answer. There is a valid need for this 'service' and I would hate to see it end just because some people see it as a way to circumvent the system.

Again, I apologize if I've offended anyone, but please try to see it from the perspective of a parent with not only a Special Child--as ALL children are Special--but a Special Needs child.
 








Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE


New Posts





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom