No more unlimited refills on resort mugs?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Our June trip was our 5th trip, and we actually did stay at Port Orleans once. Maybe I missed all the CM servicing the drink the station, but I sure don't remember them. In fact, the one time that a running child knocked my drink out of my hand (at Pop Century) I couldn't find a CM so I told one of the ladies at the register and she had someone clean up the spill.

Like I said, I always buy the mugs for everyone on every trip, but I do so for the convenience and not so much for the savings. I just hope that fixing the problem of stealing soda doesn't create inconvenience for those of us who have always paid.

Perhaps there are less CMs at the values than the moderates, or just that the value food courts are much larger. This is a wild guess only. I haven't stayed at the values, just POR and POFQ.

I'm curious about the drink systems myself. Solves some problems, creates some other new, unforeseen problems.
 
dif. reservation numbers or not, it is still ONE vacation. (who goes home and says "i just went on 3 vacations?" disney provide magical express at the beginning and end of the entire stay. they transfer your luggage from one resort to the other for free. they WANT you to try more expensive resorts and would not penalize you for doing what they encourage you to do.

so you who insist a split stay is 2 or 3 dif vacations, you purchased , say 4 mugs, then, 3 days later, purchased another 4 (exact same) mugs, then 3 days later, AGAIN purchased 4 more mugs. I doubt there is one person who actually did that.

and again, if you read the sticky at the beg. of the refillable mug thread, you will see that the dis mods agree with me.
 
Ok, I'm doing a split stay at two different resorts. Do I have to buy mugs for each resort?

That sorta used to be the case when each resort had it's own style mug. Altho many people went ahead and used em at both resorts anyway.

Today, the mugs are pretty much all the same. So there's hardly any point. And honestly, if you ask at any Disney resort and explain the split trip, they'll tell you .. they put more weight on the "for the duration of your trip" portion than they do "at the resort where you bought it."

................
that was copied from the sticky at the beg. of the refillable mug thread. note: "duration of your trip" trip, single, not plural, one trip. viola!
 
That sticky is written assuming "you can" means "no one will stop you." But, Disney's written material over the past many years has always been pretty clear; only at the resort at which you purchased it, for the duration of your stay. Whether split-stays at a single resort are "one stay" or not is not as clearly defined, but I'm guessing if you asked Disney's accountants, I know the answer they'd give you...
 

It is nice of Disney to allow people to bring their own food into the parks. They don't have to let people bring in food, and they would make make more money if they didn't. Most parks are not as accomodating.

You don't have to be a lemming to see that either.

As far as not "allowing" them to take more things away from us, the only way to stop it would be for enough people to stop going to WDW to make them take notice. And I am just not willing to do that. I think it the grand scheme of things what they have taken away is not that big a deal. Maybe you have reached your limit but I have not.


I agree that I've not yet reached my limit, but there may be a time when I will. There are certain things that make our annual (sometimes more than annual) Disney trip great for us, and it isn't the great attractions in the parks (although that's a part of it). For us, its the little things. The great CMs, the convenience at the food court (we LOVE the refillable mugs - they're fun and easy and they represent a feeling of "plenty" on vacation), the free dining codes, and lots of little fun things that make Disney better - including being allowed to bring water bottles and snacks into the parks. If there is a time when there are no good discounts, when things are no longer "easy," when all of the CM's are grouchy, etc., then maybe that will be when Disney is no longer worth it.
 
That sticky is written assuming "you can" means "no one will stop you." But, Disney's written material over the past many years has always been pretty clear; only at the resort at which you purchased it, for the duration of your stay. Whether split-stays at a single resort are "one stay" or not is not as clearly defined, but I'm guessing if you asked Disney's accountants, I know the answer they'd give you...
Well no matter what's written on the mugs or what's said in the sticky thread, since all the Quick Service locations in the resorts sell the same exact mug design, how many guests do you honestly believe purchase the same mug twice when doing a split stay?
 
Well no matter what's written on the mugs or what's said in the sticky thread, since all the Quick Service locations in the resorts sell the same exact mug design, how many guests do you honestly believe purchase the same mug twice when doing a split stay?

The question isn't "What do most people do?" The question is: "What's the policy?"

The policy is: at the resort you purchased it, for that stay only. Everyone can agree that the policy is roundly ignored---that's why they are trying this test at Sports in the first place. That doesn't change Disney's intent, which is clearly stated. Furthermore, we don't really know whether RFID will end up being deployed across property, and if so exactly what it will allow or not allow.

For what it's worth, my money says that they will see enough increased mug/cup sales at Sports to make this change worth it, and we will see these dispensers installed elsewhere in short order.

Reading between the lines of ValidFill's web site, I'm going to guess that split-stays at the same resort won't be an issue. I doubt they will bother to integrate the system with the reservation database; instead each mug will be given some fixed lifetime designed to cover the vast majority of guest stays with a comfortable margin. I've seen the number "two weeks" bandied about, and that sounds about right. If someone really has a single contiguous stay that is longer than the default period, my guess is that they will be able to either exchange their mugs at no charge, or have their existing ones reprogrammed.

However, it's an open question whether the RFID tags will be resort-specific. I suspect they will be, but that's only a guess---based in part on Disney's surprising consistency in mentioning "at your Resort" in all of the dining plan brochures, etc. I could be wrong on that, and time will tell.
 
Well no matter what's written on the mugs or what's said in the sticky thread, since all the Quick Service locations in the resorts sell the same exact mug design, how many guests do you honestly believe purchase the same mug twice when doing a split stay?[/QUOTE]


:thumbsup2

The question isn't "What do most people do?" The question is: "What's the policy?"The policy is: at the resort you purchased it, for that stay only. Everyone can agree that the policy is roundly ignored---that's why they are trying this test at Sports in the first place. That doesn't change Disney's intent, which is clearly stated. Furthermore, we don't really know whether RFID will end up being deployed across property, and if so exactly what it will allow or not allow.

For what it's worth, my money says that they will see enough increased mug/cup sales at Sports to make this change worth it, and we will see these dispensers installed elsewhere in short order.

Reading between the lines of ValidFill's web site, I'm going to guess that split-stays at the same resort won't be an issue. I doubt they will bother to integrate the system with the reservation database; instead each mug will be given some fixed lifetime designed to cover the vast majority of guest stays with a comfortable margin. I've seen the number "two weeks" bandied about, and that sounds about right. If someone really has a single contiguous stay that is longer than the default period, my guess is that they will be able to either exchange their mugs at no charge, or have their existing ones reprogrammed.However, it's an open question whether the RFID tags will be resort-specific. I suspect they will be, but that's only a guess---based in part on Disney's surprising consistency in mentioning "at your Resort" in all of the dining plan brochures, etc. I could be wrong on that, and time will tell.


this is what I think also, this is how it should be.. we are actually coming up on a 15 night stay. we plan on purchasing one new mug each for our vacation. I'm pretty darn sure, if they institute this new system at all the resorts, accomodations will be made for things like this and "sister" resorts. you may have to speak to a CM, but I assure you, we will either be getting a new chip, or new mug for free; not purchasing 3 mugs each. that is ridiculous.


That sticky is written assuming "you can" means "no one will stop you." But, Disney's written material over the past many years has always been pretty clear; only at the resort at which you purchased it, for the duration of your stay. Whether split-stays at a single resort are "one stay" or not is not as clearly defined, but I'm guessing if you asked Disney's accountants, I know the answer they'd give you...

nowhere in the sticky does it say "you can" anyways. it says "they put more weight on "the duration of your trip" portion then they do "at the resort you bought it at."


regardless, whatever anyone's opinion of what they think the Disney policy is. in the "one and only refillable mug thread" ... No debates..... it is stated in the sticky that, for the purposes of discussion on the disboards, the policy is that it is ok to purchase one mug per person of the entire split stay. period.
 
hey there jeff!
the mugs are, I believe $13.99

Hey!!

How's it going? I did a lot reading the board today. Between the cutback on the refillable mugs, the cutbacks on the monorail hours and the Brazilian tour groups I just had to chime in. My latest post is under the downhill thread. LOL!

Hope you and your husband are doing fantastic!

pirate:
 
thanks jeff! we're godd. our next split stay trip is being funded by the $ we saved by quitting smoking in January!!! :banana:
 
about $5 a pack by us. check my siggie. CBR, the BLT, then AKL. we always stay onsite. hubby will do a trip report again.
 
The only thing I would really worry about is people not knowing what to do with this high tech drinking system, and having to wait in a long line to fill up my mug.

As far as the split stay thing goes, if I paid 40 bucks for my family of 3 to have a mug for my two night stay at a value resort, and then I go check into a deluxe resort, only to be told that I have to pay another 40 bucks, I would say "no thankyou we will drink water". I know it is only 40 bucks, but it is the principle. I shouldn't be penalized for enjoying two Disney resorts. I would have to imagine that the mugs say, "refills at your resort", so people don't purchase the mug with the thought that they can have unlimited refills in the parks all day long. (which I know some people do because I have worked at Disney (MK), and had people ask me where they can refill their mug). Of course I guess that means you can't use your mug at other resorts, but how many people a day really spend hours on Disney transpertation to go to other resorts CS to fill up their mugs? What I am saying is if someone is spending two weeks at Disney, but at different Disney Resorts, they should be able to use their mugs at both resorts. Disney can do what they want, but there is no way I would come home with 6 mugs for my family of 3 because I choose to do a split stay rather then spending all 7 nights at one resort. I will go without the mug, thank you.
 
I think it is sad that people will bring their cup back on future trips
If you are that tint on cash then you prov shouldn't be spending the money on vacatioto begin with
 
I have a refillabe that I have been bringing with me for years. It's called a Brita. Can't beat the taste!!
 
I don't know the exact ounces, but the new mugs are much smaller than the pre-2000 ones.

I don't remember when they switched from the old size to the new...it had to be around 2005ish...and I know CSR held out longer than anyone - heck, they may still have the old CSR mugs there, for all I know - but the old mugs were bigger, cuter and resort-specific.

Although I like the current mugs (HM and beach versions), the newer, non-resort-specific mugs are generally generic and/or ugly. They're also very small. If you use a normal amount of ice, they won't hold a can of pop.

I have an old DIXIE LANDING mug from 1995 and although it is much larger than the mugs of today--it holds the same amount of soda as the newer ones.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.







New Posts









Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top