Next Food Network Star

I'm so glad Aria is gone. I have no idea how she got this far. I know the judges were bowled over by her so-called effervescent personality. But, really, it was so clearly an act, it felt forced to me.
 
I'm so glad Aria is gone. I have no idea how she got this far. I know the judges were bowled over by her so-called effervescent personality. But, really, it was so clearly an act, it felt forced to me.

I really liked her in the beginning and I thought I would love all her dishes but the longer she was on and using her POV I lost interest. It was like she wasn't making anything other than that nights dinner. I still can't believe she put that spread in front of the Iron Chefs, I was embarrassed for her :scared1:
 
I would watch Aarti. Tom is too spastic and over the top for my taste. His choices for Iron Chef were very odd.

I also like Herb but at this point am interested in learning more about Indian Cooking.
 
I actually like Tom. But Aarti will probably beat him.

Serving buffet food to a bunch of Iron Chefs will get you kicked off before serving them shoe leather will, who knew.
 

I actually like Tom. But Aarti will probably beat him.

Serving buffet food to a bunch of Iron Chefs will get you kicked off before serving them shoe leather will, who knew.
Well, at least Tom followed the challenge, and showed some degree of creativity, even if it didn't work! Aria completely ignored the main ingredient, had no creativity, and then didn't do it well anyway!

I thought it was really interesting, though - shrimp is a much easier "secret ingredient" than bacon, since shrimp is often the "star" of the dish which bacon is more of a side. It felt a bit like they stacked the deck in favor of Aarti and Herb.
 
Well, at least Tom followed the challenge, and showed some degree of creativity, even if it didn't work! Aria completely ignored the main ingredient, had no creativity, and then didn't do it well anyway!

ITA, she treated the challenge like she was a short order cook and not a chef. Even if his food wasn't perfect Tom was definitely competing in the spirit of Iron Chef.
 
So Tom's still there and Aria went home? Whew! I recorded it, and I'm planning to watch it tonight. But I switched over and saw that Tom and Aria were in the bottom two. "Noooo!" I thought about Tom possibly leaving, but now I know I can watch the whole show since I know he's not going to get eliminated. That's why I record shows-I'm not good with suspense.
 
I really liked her in the beginning and I thought I would love all her dishes but the longer she was on and using her POV I lost interest. It was like she wasn't making anything other than that nights dinner. I still can't believe she put that spread in front of the Iron Chefs, I was embarrassed for her :scared1:

Me too. I think that this was the most difficult challenge to date and it really identified who has the culinary chops to host a show and who does not. Aria turned into a schoolgirl and a not too bright one at that, as soon as she got in front of the camera and began talking to Alton.

I love family food and think that showing how to make simple suppers shine is a wonderful idea for a show. I agree that Aria was simple making dinner after a while.
 
I really think that Aarti is going to win this whole thing, but I also keep thinking about the "runner-up" syndrome, where the runner-up may get a chance at a show.

We all know that Aarti has some confidence problems in front of the camera. Because of this, part of me keeps thinking that maybe she'll be the runner-up, where they will have more time to work with her and get her to shed that shyness. :confused3

Tom is really the only one who seems "camera-ready" tomorrow, but his cooking chops aren't really up to par. What we need is a hybrid, the perfect winner for this season ... Tomaarti!
 
I thought it was really interesting, though - shrimp is a much easier "secret ingredient" than bacon, since shrimp is often the "star" of the dish which bacon is more of a side. It felt a bit like they stacked the deck in favor of Aarti and Herb.

I agree. Now, if it comes down to Aarti and Herb.. I'd vote for Herb. Aarti annoys me and I don't like Indian food. Go Herb!

ETA: I was actually rooting for Brad, so the rest of these guys are just "eh" to me.
 
Serving buffet food to a bunch of Iron Chefs will get you kicked off before serving them shoe leather will, who knew.

They already know Tom can cook. So I think his enthusiasm for serving horrific food rightfully trumped Aria's bland food and bland presentation. Tom aced the commentary, and Aria was lousy at both. Aria has nothing to teach us. I know how to fry up some bacon and serve it buffet style. I don't need her to show me how to do that. And I think that was her biggest problem... she had nothing interesting to share. They had How to Boil Water a couple years ago, and I loved that show. If she had gone after that as a POV (teaching non-cooks how to cook), I think that may have helped her more than her boring "this is what we eat when my ex comes to dinner once a week" M.O.

On that note, I think Herb should have been the winner in the Shrimp Battle. Aarti's commentary was SO BAD and they said that counted as half of the competition. Herb did a great job, except for his direct-to-camera thing. And one of his dishes was great, another got really good reviews (and he knew right away what was wrong with it). So mathetically, he beat her.

I'm hoping they realize how good on camera Herb is in general. During the competition he definitely had problems with it, but the camera loves him. I think there's a huge difference from competing in front of the camera and working in front of the camera.

He's my top pick.... followed by Tom. Sadly, I will not watch Aarti's show. Indian food isn't even on my radar.
 
They already know Tom can cook. So I think his enthusiasm for serving horrific food rightfully trumped Aria's bland food and bland presentation. Tom aced the commentary, and Aria was lousy at both. Aria has nothing to teach us. I know how to fry up some bacon and serve it buffet style. I don't need her to show me how to do that. And I think that was her biggest problem... she had nothing interesting to share. They had How to Boil Water a couple years ago, and I loved that show. If she had gone after that as a POV (teaching non-cooks how to cook), I think that may have helped her more than her boring "this is what we eat when my ex comes to dinner once a week" M.O.

On that note, I think Herb should have been the winner in the Shrimp Battle. Aarti's commentary was SO BAD and they said that counted as half of the competition. Herb did a great job, except for his direct-to-camera thing. And one of his dishes was great, another got really good reviews (and he knew right away what was wrong with it). So mathetically, he beat her.

I'm hoping they realize how good on camera Herb is in general. During the competition he definitely had problems with it, but the camera loves him. I think there's a huge difference from competing in front of the camera and working in front of the camera.

He's my top pick.... followed by Tom. Sadly, I will not watch Aarti's show. Indian food isn't even on my radar.

That bolded part got old for me very quickly. It was uncomfortable.
 
I think (and hope) Tom will win it..... we shall see.
 
That bolded part got old for me very quickly. It was uncomfortable.
You know, you're right - the "family dinners" did get old. Didn't she start the competition as "I'm going on an adventure, and you're invited"? Somehow I remember that from the first camera challenge she won. And then somehow she decided that "homey" was better than "adventure." Not to me, it's not.
 
You know, you're right - the "family dinners" did get old. Didn't she start the competition as "I'm going on an adventure, and you're invited"? Somehow I remember that from the first camera challenge she won. And then somehow she decided that "homey" was better than "adventure." Not to me, it's not.

I think that she was nto prepared to continue her "adventure". In order to do that week after week she would have to have a lot of new creations in her basket and I do not think that she does. She reminded me of Paula Dean in the beginning. SHe was funny, charming and very comfortable. As soon as she got out of her comfort zone she got crankish, false and over worked. Where Paula was able to add new dishes, and most were homey dishes, Aria was not. I also think tha tAria does nto know how to share any of her cooking skills and so her commentary comes across as condescending. After watching the Iron Chef battle though, I think she could stand to learn a thing or two.

That bolded part got old for me very quickly. It was uncomfortable.

You got that right! I really did not need to know that, I am not a fan of TMI!
 
Rooting for Tom this season! :)
 
snykymom said:
You know, you're right - the "family dinners" did get old. Didn't she start the competition as "I'm going on an adventure, and you're invited"?
Yep. They even replayed that scene on the After Party show on Cooking Channel.
 
LuvCuteBoys said:
On that note, I think Herb should have been the winner in the Shrimp Battle. Aarti's commentary was SO BAD and they said that counted as half of the competition. Herb did a great job, except for his direct-to-camera thing. And one of his dishes was great, another got really good reviews (and he knew right away what was wrong with it). So mathetically, he beat her.

I'm hoping they realize how good on camera Herb is in general. During the competition he definitely had problems with it, but the camera loves him. I think there's a huge difference from competing in front of the camera and working in front of the camera.
Herb had one great, one "eh", and one bad dish. Aarti had three great dishes. Herb did very good in the presentation. Aarti did bad. It probably averaged out that Aarti did somewhat - not outstandingly - better.

That said, I wouldn't believe for a second that any Food Network show is filmed/taped beginning to end with no errors, cuts, or editing (not even 30 Minute Meals ;)). If Herb wins, and stumbles on a line, the scene can be redone, no?
 
I feel like they're wasting airtime till Aarti wins...:rolleyes: I don't like a THING about her and again, they'll give a show to someone I won't watch. A shame because I think the others would've been something I'd watch, even Aria.:surfweb:
 
An interview that popped up on AOL this evening.:surfweb:

This week's eliminated star was Aria Kagan, a working mother and former chef-instructor from Miami, Florida. She started out the season as one of the front-runners, winning the judges over with her bubbly personality and ease in front of the camera. With her "family style" point of view, she seemed a natural fit for the network's audience. But as the weeks wore on, she was criticized for her sometimes over-the-top enthusiasm and lackluster dishes. Last night's Iron Chef challenge didn't play to her strengths. Instead of showcasing her secret ingredient (bacon), she used it as a side dish for a family-style French-toast breakfast and atop a pedestrian Waldorf salad. The judges felt the food wasn't Iron Chef-worthy, and sent her home.

Slashfood spoke with Aria about creating a TV concept, presenting in front of Bobby Flay and her frustrations with the judging process.

So tell me about the day after.
AK: Oh my gosh. It's so funny to be a part of the show and experience the whole challenge and then to see it edited and put together. It was such a whirlwind. I don't remember much of it.

How long has it been since you left the set?
AK: This was all taped earlier in the year. It was springtime when we shot this.

I think people have the perception that you just found out yesterday.
AK: I think that's what the Food Network would like everyone to believe. It's funny, because it was really, really hard to leave. We really did become very close. And I had to go through this whole mourning process and kicking myself for making a bad decision, and now I have to do it all over again, because people are seeing it for the first time. I have to relive it. Not one of my fondest moments, but nonetheless it is what it is.

You had to keep this secret for months.
AK: Yeah! And I had to keep the secret that I was on the show, too! They told me I got the show in November, and then I couldn't tell anyone until the end of April. And I'm not a good secret keeper. If you want someone to know something, you tell me.

They spend the whole season hammering home how important "point of view" is, and then you were sent home for emphasizing your point of view ("Family Style") in the Iron Chef Challenge. Were you surprised?
AK: Part of me was frustrated, because they really did love my food. As much as they didn't show it last night, they really did think a lot of my ideas were new and inventive and fresh. But at the same time they thought I didn't follow through with the challenge properly. Tom, he went another way. He was totally like, "I'm going to do something Iron Chef and crazy" but his food wasn't good. I wanted the judges to feel like they were walking into my house on a Saturday morning and eating what I would make them for breakfast. So, you know, you live and you learn.

And the edit wasn't the kindest.
AK: Right. The edit was very unkind to me. And it was sad to watch because I felt so good when I left, because I did show them the person that I was, and what "family style" was all about. They were so complimentary of my food throughout the whole process, so to see it edited that way was kind of frustrating. But you know, when you sign up for something like this, you have to take the good with the bad.

And how much of a factor were the judges during last night's episode? You were cooking in front of the Iron Chefs and having to chat with Alton. Was that a little intense?
AK: I wasn't really intimidated by them -- to me, they're just people, people who love food the way I love food. Alton was a little intimidating though, and it was very loud, so a couple of times I didn't hear what he said. When I look like I don't know what he's saying, it was often that I just couldn't hear. I was like "What? Is someone talking to me?"

You were definitely painted as a front-runner from the beginning of the season. Do you think that might have hurt you?
AK: I think the judges had a lot of expectations of me, whereas with Tom they didn't. We're all going through the same process of trying to find ourselves. I went out into the first challenge with the attitude, "If they like me, they like me, if they don't, they don't -- but I have to just be myself." But then they didn't like my original show idea, "Farm to Table." So I was trying to reinvent a show that they would enjoy where I could also be myself. I wanted to please them so desperately, and wanted to get the show so badly, that I think I lost my passion along the way.

What made you try out in the first place? This is season six, so you had to kind of know what you were getting into.
AK: You never know what you're getting into. I went into it very blind. I'd always wanted my own cooking show and thought, "here's my chance." I was going back and forth, debating whether to audition for it, and my mom bought me a plane ticket and said, "You're going!" In life, sometimes you need people to believe in you a little bit more than you believe in yourself.

You have a young son, and that obviously made things harder. How did you guys keep in touch?
AK: In the beginning, I was able to call, but then around week three, they stopped calls from coming in or going out. One of the producers was able to call and make sure everything was ok and tell them that I was fine, but after that, I didn't have any connection with him until episode eight. [The contestants were reunited with their families on camera as part of a challenge for this episode.]

No wonder everyone was so emotional.
AK: Yeah, we were all dying to see our families.

Last night, when the judges were deliberating, Bobby Flay said you were "born to talk to the lens." It's obvious you have on-camera talent. Are you going to pursue a television career?
AK: Honestly, I would still love to have my own cooking show incorporating the whole farm-to-table idea. I want to show people where their food comes from in a cool, fun, sexy way. I have a blog where I'm going to be documenting a lot of this, and posting recipes. On the show, I'm a character. On any reality show, you have the characters. And I want people to see me for who I am. The Food Network really sets you up. Millions of people have seen me. And I hope someone says, "I've seen her, I like her, let's work with her."
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer

New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom