Richyams,
As always you grossly exaggerate the differences in pts, dues, etc. You completely ignore such factors as various pt seasons, the lower standard pt rooms at BWV, etc. I especially would not be tooting about lower OKW dues; first dues are anything but a constant--they fluctuate from yr to yr; secondly, OKW has had the highest % of dues increase out of all the WDW
DVC resorts for the past several years; and with the new addition of a pool slide, main pool refurbishment, additional costs for life guards, etc. at OKW---it is most likely this trend will continue for awhile.
But I do agree with you, that to many the superior location to parks, numerous dining options, entertainment, etc is well worth the higher cost and the loss of a bigger and unwanted kitchen, a larger dining table and a slightly larger lr that an OKW villa gives. The vast majority of the size difference in a 1 br or larger OKW villa, including the GV is in the larger kitchen/dining area and the laundry room. Hey, whatever floats your boat, if cooking meals and doing laundry is your thing on vacation--go for it!!!!! Many vacationers like to be pampered and waited on during vacation and cooking meals or a large kitchen is not high on the priority list.
WDW resorts are like resorts anywhere else, the closer you are to the main hub, the better the convenience to major attractions, dining options etc.--- the more expensive and highly rated/desired the resort is. Just think about any vacation destination--the further you get from the main hub and the greatly decreased ease of convenience, the fewer resort guest services/amenities, etc.---the cheaper the price of the resort is. A resort located just 10 - 15 mins from the main hub not only has lower prices but also many times, provides larger accommondations. What you lose in location and convenience you trade off for lower costs and larger rooms.
Yes, I would say to many travelers all over, the lack of a larger kitchen or a villa with less sq footage is well worth the superior location and convenience. Just price out non WDW resorts sometime, for the heck of it.