My daughter has to make a raffle gift basket for the charity she is representing- a local food bank. They will have these baskets out at an event and the money will go to all the charities. I guess we'll just put food in it and maybe a grocery gift card. I don't know whether to put in food that the food pantry says they need or something else.
I would say something else. If it's a raffle basket, then the food inside will be going to the person who wins the raffle, not the food bank. I think your best bet is to go with a theme of some sort. I'll give you a couple of ideas, get creative and add some more stuff that you think of.
Italin theme: Boxes of Pasta, Olive Oil, Balsamic Vinegar, Good Quality Jar Spaghetti Sauce (Rao for example), jarred olives, roasted peppers, some placemats and napkins, etc. Here are some pictures of Italian Theme gift baskets to give you additional ideas:
http://www.gourmetgiftbaskets.com/Italian-Gift-Baskets.asp
http://www.gourmetgiftbaskets.com/Italian-Gift-Baskets.asp
Ice Cream Sundae Gift Basket: Ice cream dishes and spoons (or Ice Cream Soda Glasses), hot fudge sauce, butterscotch sauce, sprinkles, maraschino cherries, gummy bears, chopped nuts, etc. and a gift certificate for a local ice cream place to buy the ice cream
Breakfast Basket: Something along these lines:
http://www.amazon.com/England-Breakfast-Gift-Basket-Standard/dp/B001F8ITLI Jellies/jams, muffin mix, pancake mix, bacon, maple syrup, cloth napkins, coffee,
A baby food one. It could include baby 'snacks', cereals, jarred food, some dishes/forks/sippy cups/a bib or burp cloth. You could use soemthing like a tote bag or a toy bin as the basket
Snack Baskets: This page shows some great themed snack baskets geared towards guys. I like the football one with the Doritos and stuff. I'd incorporate the local team somehow (using the colors in the wrapping and maybe a pennant or something) and I'd get as creative as possible with the basket/container (a cooler for a guys snack one, for example).
I think the more you can play up the theme (and of course include lots of food!) the more appealing the basket will be. You can take ideas from several of these themes and combine them or use local products.