Here is how our stay was...(thanks for the nudge Pamela)
We made a last minute reservation for a last minute trip and didn't have time to do much research. We have stayed at Buena Vista Suites before as well as the value resorts so that is my basis for comparison.
We like the value resorts because of all that is Disney. We liked BVS because with a family of 6 we could stay in one room, it was clean, it was close to Disney and the price was right. As for Comfort Suites Maingate East, we liked it better than BVS. CSME scores better than BVS in the following areas...a little cleaner, nicer pool & cost. BSV scores better than CSME in the following areas...central air vs window units, the living room is not seperated from the bedroom & better breakfast.
Here are the costs before taxes that we were chosing from...
Value resort(2 rooms) $198/night
BVS $89/night(Th&F) $139/night Sat
CSME $69/night
We said that we would stay at CSME again so I hope this helps. Let me know if you have any questions.