Narcoossees or Citricos

[Lynn5700]

Which would you choose and why??? I'm torn between the two.

 

[lacrosse_lady72]

Go to both, I am.

We go to Narcoossee's every year- I love the caesar salad, I love the drinks there (favorite is the Raspberry Mojitocoosee), I loved the filet in 2007, I realized I wasn't a lobster person in 2008 and the almond crusted cheesecake is to die for.

I can let you know which one come October 3 though since we're going to both for our upcoming trip.

 

[aubriee]

Hmm, tough choice. They are both very good. Citricos feels a little more upscale for some reason, but food is wonderful at both. Due to the surf & turf and the decadent almond cheesecake I'd give a very slight edge to Narcoosee's though. That cheesecake is my all time favorite dessert at WDW.

I agree with the previous poster, go to both if you can. I plan to during my Sept/Oct trip. lol

 

[Lynn5700]

We could do both, but I have my other restaurants picked so I can only fit in one.

I just noticed that there is lobster at Narcooses. Tim loves it!! I think he would enjoy it I wil have to show him both menues and have him pick. I think you get more our of the deluxe dining plan with Narcooses. Hmmmm.

 

[ROEDISNEY]

I have been to both. Hard choice. Luv Both! But it depends on what u feel like eating to. If I could only pick one then it would be Citricos. But either place you can't go wrong.

 

[Pakey]

I definitely prefer Citricos over Narcoosees. The food is better and the atmosphere is definitely more adult (most of the time).

 

[disbridemimi]

We LOVE Narcoosees! My DF doesn't eat seafood, and he still loved it. He got steak. We also LOVED the desserts there! And of course, its very romantic if you want to watch Wishes, everyone shuffles out onto the deck.

It is pricy, so I think with the delux dining plan it would be an excellent time to give it a try. We LOVED it! We did it as our fancy date night. We also enjoyed the electrical water pageant, which no one else wanted to stay to watch.


PS We also enjoyed eating with a view of the castle changing colors. Its such a pretty water front spot

 

[pinkpixie0920]

We are doing Narcossee's in September (as long as our ADR's work out next Sunday) mainly because of the surf an turf. I have heard wonderful things about both though.

 

[EpcotSweetHrts0512]

We have this dilemma too!! From what I've read on the menus, it seems like my husband and I would like Narcoosee's better... I guess we will have to go to one this trip and the other one on our next trip!

 

[ScottJoseph]

I'd recommend Citricos, and my reasons are listed in my reviews of both restaurants. Here's Citricos, and here's Narcoossee's.

Scott
[URL="http://www.scottjosephorlando.com/"]Scott Joseph's Orlando Restaurant Guide[/URL]

 

[kathiewe]

Thanks Scott. We are planning to try Citricos this fall. We are looking forward to a great experience.

 

[pianoronni37]

Lynn, we are in the same predicament! We have all of our meals picked out, and when it comes to the GF we can't decide between Citrico's and Narcoossee's!

I'm *thinking* of swaying on Narcoossee's because of the lobster and the almond-crusted cheesecake... although each time I look at Citrico's menu, I'm back to square one!

Ahh, these decisions... if we didn't have them to make, planning wouldn't be nearly as fun!

 

[tinacaplan]

um...i have to call both reviews into question. you seem to purport that you know food, yet you dismiss arancini, seemingly not realizing that they are a staple dish of real italian cooking. and ham on an antipasti platter? surely you did not mean domestic boiled ham or a smoked virginia ham, because the only "ham" italians make is proscuitto.

 

[ROEDISNEY]

um...i have to call both reviews into question. you seem to purport that you know food, yet you dismiss arancini, seemingly not realizing that they are a staple dish of real italian cooking. and ham on an antipasti platter? surely you did not mean domestic boiled ham or a smoked virginia ham,
because the only "ham" italians make is proscuitto.

And Proscuitto is the BEST!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[MRS AR]

Another vote for Narcoossees!

 

[Lynn5700]

Ok guys! Thanks for your input. When I showed Tim both menues, he freaked when he saw lobster. So Narcoossees it is LOL.

Thank's a lot for the help.

 

[lacrosse_lady72]

um...i have to call both reviews into question. you seem to purport that you know food, yet you dismiss arancini, seemingly not realizing that they are a staple dish of real italian cooking. and ham on an antipasti platter? surely you did not mean domestic boiled ham or a smoked virginia ham, because the only "ham" italians make is proscuitto.

YES! You tell him. Although i appreciate the time he takes to write these reviews, I always seem to disagree with a lot said in the reviews

 

[lacrosse_lady72]

Ok guys! Thanks for your input. When I showed Tim both menues, he freaked when he saw lobster. So Narcoossees it is LOL.

Thank's a lot for the help.

I am glad you were able to pick one! I don't think you'd be upset with either and I am sure you'll eventually try both since it's not as if you'll never be back to WDW.

 

[Lynn5700]

HAHA that's true!! Thanks again!

 

[purpliequeen]

Narcoosee's! Hands down one of my favorite restaurants at Disney.