Now, if you lasted through my long-windedness (I'm even worse in person), here's our plan of places to try:
Ohana (repeat for us but we just love it)
Biergarten (Justin's request)
Le Cellier
Trails End (Breakfast - Wanted to try it for dinner but breakfast fit better)
Raglan Road (I'm in it for the bread pudding & I've been wanting to return since I did not love it the first time)
Narcoossee's (My pick. I'm in it for the lobster/filet combo and the almond crusted cheesecake)
Tusker House (This one's negotiable but we do want to spend some time at AK. If not this, maybe Sanaa for lunch).
So the only one that's not new to Justin is Ohana, and I've only been to Ohana, Tusker House, and Raglan Road. Lots of new places!