Maya Grill, Turf Club, Shutters?

[mouser_momof2]

I'm debating changing my Tony's ADR to one of these 3....

Looked back about 10 pages and didn't see any one of these listed.

The Maya Grill menu looks yummy, but is it good?

I'm so torn!

 

[BEASLYBOO]

We love the Turf Club. The food is really good, great prime rib, my son always has the rack of lamb. It's got a nice vibe and the service is good, it a little hidden gem!

 

[DisneySarah80]

Can't say first hand, but in my opinion, if there are no threads about these restaurants, there must be a reason.... Just a thought! *0*

 

[BEASLYBOO]

Can't say first hand, but in my opinion, if there are no threads about these restaurants, there must be a reason.... Just a thought! *0*

Not necessarily true, some of the resort restaurants don't get the traffic that the park restaurants get. To their credit they tend to be a bit less expensive. The Turf Club at SSR is one of the few spots that offers prime rib at Disney and tasty prime rib at that. Can't comment on Maya or Shutter's, I've not eaten at either!

I only eat at the Turf Club if I'm staying at SSR/OKW next door.

 

[PiperMickey]

We love the Turf Club. The food is really good, great prime rib, my son always has the rack of lamb. It's got a nice vibe and the service is good, it a little hidden gem!

Couldn't agree more.

We have been to the Turf club for lunch and dinner, and enjoy it very much.

 

[Robin K]

We ate at Maya Grill last Sept (2010) and thought it was great! We went back this Sept and it wasn't great AT ALL. The server told us they change the menus about every 3 months..we were less than thrilled by the changes. We-mom and myself- did find to eat but we were not impressed.
I can't comment on the other places because we haven't been there.
Hope this helps!

 

[winterman]

We have been to the Turf Club twice for dinner and it is now on our list of 'must do's. DH loves the lamb chops. It has a great atsmosphere. We haven't eaten on the deck but I certainly would in the right weather.

 

[mouser_momof2]

I appreciate the input! The Maya Grill menu looks good to me. It did last trip as well, but I was the only one that wanted to try it.... I think I'm about 98% on my ADr's right now... I'm fixing to post a "rate my ADR's thread" lol.

 

[DCDisney]

Glad to see the raves about Turf Club. We have spa appointments and Turf Club is the right place at the right time for us and great food is total bonus

 

[lizzytizzy]

We ate at Maya Grill last Sept (2010) and thought it was great! We went back this Sept and it wasn't great AT ALL. The server told us they change the menus about every 3 months..we were less than thrilled by the changes. We-mom and myself- did find to eat but we were not impressed.
I can't comment on the other places because we haven't been there.
Hope this helps!

what did you have?

 

[Cafeen]

We ate at Maya Grill last Sept (2010) and thought it was great! We went back this Sept and it wasn't great AT ALL. The server told us they change the menus about every 3 months..we were less than thrilled by the changes. We-mom and myself- did find to eat but we were not impressed.
I can't comment on the other places because we haven't been there.
Hope this helps!

Strangely enough, I had the exact opposite experience . 2010 it wasn't very good, and 2011 it was. Just goes to show how tastes differ.

However, I would comment that it's not really a place to go out of your way for. If you have the extra time and you're touring resorts, or if you're staying at CSR, it's worth a try. Otherwise, I wouldn't think it's entirely worth it (and I did enjoy it ).