LOVE this thread! Thanks so much for starting!
I started Atkins in October of 2011. By the end of day 3, when the cravings were gone and I was in control of what I put in my mouth instead of food being in control of me, I felt like I had conquered Everest! Energy went through the roof and my mood improvement was off the charts. I was completely hooked and have never looked back.
It's not easy, and my mindset is that I am not on a diet. My Way of Eating (WOE) is a lifestyle change that I will keep for the rest of my life.
There are days/weeks/months when those plateaus are daunting and the frustration with the scale (my nemisis! I can hear Doofenshmirtz singing the song) seems overwehlming. But I've kept a few pieces of clothing in my closet from before, and I pull those out when neccessary as a reminder of just how far I've come.
The first three months, we lost our dear dog to a very sudden illness, got though Halloween, Thanksgiving, Christmas and New Year's without a single deviation from Induction (I had A LOT to loose, so that phase was much longer for me). And I realized that I wasn't weak, but rather misguided in terms of what foods worked for my body.
We got a puppy. A golden retriver mix that had to be walked A LOT. So add in the personal pup trainer and the weight loss kicked into high gear.
I'm down 125 lbs and still going. One of my friends talked me into walking a half marathon in Sept of 2012, and I caught the race bug. 5k, 10k, 10 miler, you name it I'm having a blast doing them. Princess Half Marathon is in a few weeks, have been training hard and can not wait for the experience. DH and I are looking at this upcoming trip as a celebration of getting my life back.
It's taken a lot of "fusion" to come up with a WOE that works for me - elements of Atkins, Paleo, South Beach...but low carb has been my literal life saver. Every person is different, and a cookie cutter diet approach that seems to be so prevalent is counter-productive, IMHO.
Will I ever be "skinny"? Not likely, I simply don't have the body type. But I am healthy, strong and vibrant. And I'm good with that!
Keep the faith!!!