SillyMe said:
WHAT???!!!!!
I agree with you Alliecats. I love the cast. I love the characters that they have developed. I wouldn't mind bringing some new ones in, but PLEASE don't take the good ones we have.
That's exactly what I was going to say before I had to rush off to check my dinner.
I think it would be really cool to encounter others on the island. Whether it's other survivors from flight 815, survivors from another flight, seawrecked survivors, crazy French hatch people...it really wouldn't matter as long as it was well written.
The thought of losing the people we have grown to love, either all of them or a majority of them, makes me sad. Admittedly Boone was not my favorite character, but now that he's gone I really miss him. I also feel like there was so much more to his story that we could have learned. I feel a little cheated now.
I understand their (writers) thoughts that if there is a reasonable explanation for everything that has happened and will happen, then it's reasonable to expect that not all survivors will live the entire length of the show. I agree, that's reasonable. BUT: killing off lots of main characters they have written in such a way that we love them is not the way to go about it. That's not reasonable IMHO. The deaths would logically occur right after the crash, then, IMO, some could occur later in the show (like 2-3 seasons from now) and still be "logical". They did a good job of tying Boone's death into the plot seamlessly. They felt a need to "off" a character to keep it real and they did a good job of it. Going after more main characters seems like they're going after the shock value. They have a great show as it is. They don't need to kill lots of characters for the shock value. The twists and turns in the writing do a good job of that.
The one bright spot I see in all of this is: JJ Abrams or Damon Lindelof said that just because a character might not come back in the second season didn't mean he/she is dead. It would be a cool story if one of them were "lost" for the second season (ahem, like Sawyer could go make a movie, do a Playgirl layout

, come visit a southern girl in Louisiana...

) while the survivors are trying to solve the mystery of what happened to him. In season 3, viola! HE'S BAAAACCKKKK!!
Anyway, as far as the deaths go, I hope they're equal opportunity killers and a female bites the dust!