For us, yes, WDW has lost its magic. We've been going for a very long time. Were Disney fanatics. Had come || close to buying
DVC and were still debating it two years ago. For many years, my dd's goal in life was to work at WDW for her career. She did two CPs in Orlando. She herself noticed a huge change between her first and second CP in terms of how they were treated, the quality of their training, and the expectation level -- and there was just one year between those two programs. It was indeed around the time of her second CP that we started to notice, as guests, the difference in quality at the Parks and attitude of the CMs. Small differences, but we did notice them. And not because we were looking, but because it was
clearly a difference from just the year before.
Then add into that the Magic Bands, FP+. We initially assumed that Disney would employ its vaunted "Disney Way" techniques to these two new items. We never ever thought we would hate these changes. We thought they would either be fine or a great improvement. So, sorry, to those of you who think we went into it with negative attitudes and got what we expected. Nope. We expected good quality.
The problem is that Disney did not deliver on basic, good customer service for us with the Magic Bands and FP+. Forget "Magic". Ha. Even if I dialed down my expectations to
Walmart level customer service, Disney would have still failed.
We never in a million years thought that Disney would rig the system so guests would get fewer FP and therefore get less value for our hard-earned money. We never thought it would take 6+ hours to arrange our vacation and make FP+ reservations because THEIR system was down/glitchy/whatever. We never thought I would have to keep calling back over and over and over to try and get a CM who would help me. We never thought we'd have so many problems getting our UnMagical Bands to work... over and over and over. We never thought that our Magic Bands would not work for room entry. For charging to our room. For park entry. Day after day, even after we'd been assured -- every day -- that they were "fixed". We never thought that Guest Relations would blame US for the fact that the UnMagical Bands did not work. We never thought that when someone called me from Disney in response to my email complaint that she would agree with me that guest service has gone downhill because training is not what it was a few years ago.
Plus I simply do not want to have to plan my days out 2 months in advance. I just don't. Not interested at all. If that's the way WDW is going to be, I'm simply not going there any more.
Then add to that the huge improvements and innovation at Universal Orlando while Disney is... well, not doing the same and has not for years. I simply cannot compare the "New Fantasyland" with Harry Potter at Universal. The Diagon Alley is without doubt the most amazing immersive experience combined with awesome HP rides in both areas, just a WOW experience. We never thought we'd find Universal a better park than WDW, but during our last visit in November, we most certainly did. Totally shocked us. And it was not just us -- our party consisted of foreign friends who'd never been to either park. I had been talking about WDW to them for
years and had not told them of my nightmare trying to book our trip. So they were
primed to love WDW. Guess what? They all preferred Universal.
Interestingly enough, we have all been to DLCA in the last year and we found that, for us, those are great parks and we plan to return. Even my dd who had been a diehard WDW fanatic says that she now prefers DLCA. So it's not about Disney per se, it's about the way WDW is being run. It's just not a good value for our money any more, it's too annoying/irritating to plan the trip, the customer service has gone down while prices are going up, and in comparison to other theme parks, it's just not giving the "magic" that makes it worth my money.