Lobster Roll.........Columbia Harbour House

[tammilynne]

I ordered it on my last trip in 2013 and liked it and would order again. Although, I don't remember it having as much mayo then as the one pictured.

 

[TiffanyA]

I would stay 20 feet away from that, but I have texture issues and I cannot stand all but a few applications of mayo (pretty much deviled eggs and tuna fish and the mayo level needs to be minimal for me). I personally like my lobster rolls "naked" and smothered in drawn butter

 

[jsmla]

I would stay 20 feet away from that, but I have texture issues and I cannot stand all but a few applications of mayo (pretty much deviled eggs and tuna fish and the mayo level needs to be minimal for me). I personally like my lobster rolls "naked" and smothered in drawn butter

That looks really good!

 

[Darkside]

I have to admit that I am drooling right now. Pretty sure I need to find one of these.

 

[fairy oma]

Have had some wonderful lobster rolls at WDW (Food & Wine and Captain's Grill) but the one at CHH ........ it was so bad I didn't finish and threw it away. ALOT of mayo and bread. I don't throw away food lightly, disappointed.

From easywdw with review -
http://www.easywdw.com/easy/blog/lo...-harbour-house-mango-gelato-from-cosmic-rays/

You must have hit CHH on a bad day, 3 out of 4 people in our group got one for lunch in Dec. 2015 and none of them had anywhere near that much mayo. I would not have like it either.

 

[chinarider]

I tried the one at Boardwalk Bakery and was disappointed

 

[Sydney2977]

DS and I tried the one at F&W a few years ago and didn't like it. But something made me want to try one again when we were at Tomorrowland Terrace earlier this month and I actually liked it.

I also am not a fan of lots of mayo (maybe that's why we didn't like the F&W one?) and hardly use any when making tuna or chicken salad and this one was just right. Maybe they should call it a lobster salad sandwich, because I can see the difference from the posted pictures of the "real thing" which doesn't look like it even uses mayo. It kind of reminds me how some bar-b-que places drown their meat in sauce, but in Texas it's all about smoking the meat- if it's got a good rub and is smoked right it doesn't need sauce. I imagine it's the same with good lobster.

 

[lauraleh]

Boardwalk Bakery has a lobster roll that is much better. More of a traditional lobster roll, just a tiny bit of mayo if any and a piece of lettuce instead of a celery mayo lobster salad that they call a lobster roll over at CHH.

 

[LindseyJo22]

I enjoyed it, but I'm from the South US and we definitely don't really get much in the way of good lobster around here. I certainly think it can be hit or miss on the amount of mayo, etc. But I've gotten it twice this year and enjoyed it both times. Thinking I may go for fish or shrimp this next time just for some variety. If you're wanting something like these other delicious looking pictures, I think it's obvious that the CHH roll isn't that! But it's definitely not bad and better than a lot of the CS options in MK in my personal opinion.

 

[Stefecatzz]

I tried it in 2013. IMO, it was too much bread & mayo & not seasoned very well. The homemade chips were absolutely delicious, though!

I really enjoyed the one at BB much better & have gotten it both times I had the DDP. It is a really good value on the plan for a QS meal.

 

[spielerin]

Lobster roll at captain's grille. A bit wet but good chunks of lobster.

 

[fieldhockeychk26]

Does anyone know if the boardwalk bakery still has its lobster roll?? Its no longer on the menu

 

[Bronxgirl]

I was excited to order it during my trip in 2013. I was disappointed that it was basically mayonnaise soup with minimal lobster bits. On my last trip I just got the salmon and it was pretty good.

 

[eastendlights]

We live in CT and vacation in Maine every summer. I warned my DD against ordering the "lobster roll" at CHH a few years back and she decided to get it anyway. Most of it ended up in the trash. Way too much mayo-it should be called mayo soup with lobster garnish-not for us! We get it a few miles from our house on the shoreline-no celery-no mayo-just lobster in butter and roll.

 

[starousse]

It wasn't my cup of tea.

 

[kittyab]

My DH is from Nova Scotia, Canada. He liked the lobster roll at this place.

 

[jess20k]

OMG!!! It was absolutely disgusting! Ugh! How dare they even call that poor thing a lobster roll. No lobster hardly, and I am afraid it was like lagastino or something like it. It was dripping with watery mayo and gross peppers. Captains Grille at the Yacht Club has an amazing Lobster Roll though.

 

[BrokeMack]

Everyone except New Englanders seem to like it. My wife likes it (I'm allergic or I'd weigh in).

 

[chrisc88]

My niece eats lobster rolls every chance she gets and she did not like this one at all.

 

[Eastern]

Have had some wonderful lobster rolls at WDW (Food & Wine and Captain's Grill) but the one at CHH ........ it was so bad I didn't finish and threw it away. ALOT of mayo and bread. I don't throw away food lightly, disappointed.

From easywdw with review -
http://www.easywdw.com/easy/blog/lo...-harbour-house-mango-gelato-from-cosmic-rays/

Seriously, I would have sent this back. Even though I've seen this pic before, every time I look at it, I feel sick. omg