Le Cellier Steakhouse or Monsieur Paul?

[Katholicchik]

Which would you choose for a birthday dinner with the fam? Both sound excellent!

 

[staceycrouton]

We ate at Le Cellier last night and it was outstanding!!!! The filet mignon was the best that I had ever had. I do not like risotto and was able to have cream cheese mashed potatoes instead, yummy!! And, of course, the pretzel bread was amazing as usual. We also had the chocolate "moose" for dessert (even though it is no longer on the adult menu, it is still on the kids menu and you are able to order it). We've never eaten at Monsieur Paul but always make it a point to eat at Le Cellier each trip. The service was impeccable as well!!! I even told my kids to remind me how much I loved my meal when I complain about Le Cellier being 2 credits when we plan our next trip to Disney!!

 

[DougDavis]

My opinion is the exact opposite. Having previously lived in Manhattan which is of course known for its steak houses both my wife and I though Le Cellier was horrible. In fact I wouldnt even rate them as high as a Ruth Chris.
I would go with Monsieur Paul, Yachtman's Steakhouse or Victoria &Albert's.

 

[Tonberry]

Monsieur Paul hands down.
Food is better, atmosphere is better, and it seems to be more quiet and enjoyable.