Well, if you want me to be honest... We were at CM last July and we didn't make PS and just went late thinking it would be ok. We ended being seated a little after 9. We were not very pleased.. They didn't seem to be putting out as much food, and what was there seemed picked over... The servers, while pleasant, seemed rushed and the character interaction was substantially less than it had been the year before when we DID make PS and were seated around 6PM... We may have been there on an off night, who knows. I do know my wife and I commented that we would not go back to a character buffet that late again, as we didn't feel we got our value for the price. It wasn't bad enough for us to say never again, but never again at that time. Maybe things will be different for you?