Kitchen countertops

My neighbor has granite. Put it in 11 years ago. It has cracked three times. But apparently it can be repaired. He's a contractor and he said he knew there was a chance of this happening before they put it in.
We put in Corian 5 years ago. No issues yet, and if there are, nothing that you can't repair yourself with a $25 repair kit.
Granite is the standard spec for the houses my company builds and in about 300 units a year, probably 5% have issues. It’s definitely not bullet-proof and the most common problem is cracking caused by extreme temperature changes. Although tons of people do it, it is definitely NOT recommended to put hot pans directly on it. The edges where the sink and stovetop cut-outs are can also break if people do stupid things like stand on them.
 
Granite is the standard spec for the houses my company builds and in about 300 units a year, probably 5% have issues. It’s definitely not bullet-proof and the most common problem is cracking caused by extreme temperature changes. Although tons of people do it, it is definitely NOT recommended to put hot pans directly on it. The edges where the sink and stovetop cut-outs are can also break if people do stupid things like stand on them.
Good info, thanks, I love my granite but I still treat it respectfully.
 
My SIL put Corian in her new house and I think it is ugly. Her cream colored sink is already stained after a couple years. The countertops are dull and show EVERYTHING.
 
My SIL put Corian in her new house and I think it is ugly. Her cream colored sink is already stained after a couple years. The countertops are dull and show EVERYTHING.
We have them at work and where the coffee pot sits is all stained. There are also some areas falling off. I think if you have them, you also have to treat them resepecfully, and if you do, they'll probably be fine, too. I lived with white grooved Formica (which I'd picked out and loved) for 20 years before we did our kitchen remodel and they were still in excellent condition (aside from the one spot where my sister cut bagels directly on the Formica grrr).
 

I'm starting this type of search also. Do any of these have to be sealed each year?
In my experience, granite does not have to be sealed every year. However, it should be checked at least once a year and preferably more than that. It's so easy to test, all you need is a couple drops of water. But virtually nobody does it. So the first sign they see that their granite needed sealing is a spill. Uh oh......And things get much harder after that occurs. An ounce of prevention in this case is worth 10 pounds of cure. Now if you never spill anything on it, you can go years and years with a granite countertop needing a seal and it will probably be ok. But again, the test is EZPZ and sealing it is not all that difficult. The 48 hours of non use is a pain in the rear. But other than that, it's not too bad So there is no excuse not to be doing it. The way I figure it, you shell out the big bucks for a granite countertop, it's worth a couple of minutes of your time every so often to check it and a couple of hours of your time when you need to seal it.
 
We upgraded to granite in our kitchen a few years ago. SO much better than the tile that was there before.
Our new house has formica, but it's in good shape so we'll probably wait a few years at least before thinking of upgrading it.
 
Granite is the standard spec for the houses my company builds and in about 300 units a year, probably 5% have issues. It’s definitely not bullet-proof and the most common problem is cracking caused by extreme temperature changes. Although tons of people do it, it is definitely NOT recommended to put hot pans directly on it. The edges where the sink and stovetop cut-outs are can also break if people do stupid things like stand on them.
Yeah, I was surprised that my daughter's entry level house had granite counter tops. And stainless steel appliances. Although when we remodeled our kitchen 5 years ago, the Sharp drawer microwave we wanted only came in stainless steel. The box still showed White and Almond (the color we wanted) as an option, but they had discontinued the two colors.
 
/
We went with a black granite and it has been great - completely trouble-free.

But....

I wish we had gone with the grey Silestone (Corian) that was our first choice. Reason being, with granite you need to consider the seams - single slabs of granite can only be so big. the contractor put the seam at the sink to keep the piece from breaking when he put it in. The seam has never really looked right. That only exacerbates the other thing we aren't 100% happy with. We wanted an apron sink but our cabinet contractor talked us out of that because they had goofed and built the cabinets for a regular below-counter double sink. First world problems for sure, but it bugs us anyway.

LSS - whatever you do, don't compromise. Get what you want and be happy with your choice. You'll be seeing it every day.
 
We went with Quartz for our kitchen a few years ago, I still love it, no regrets. I read granite needed to be sealed periodically, so went the lazier approach. Glad to see the kelly green formica (builder's supplied) go away!
 
In my experience the only people that think sealing is a big deal are Corian and quartz countertop salesmen. :rotfl2:

That has been our experience as well. Quartz is made by grinding up the material and using some type of epoxy to make the slabs. Much of this is a matter of personal preference as well as budget. I would never use marble in a kitchen since common products with acid (i.e. lemon juice, pop, vinegar, ....etc.) can etch the surface.

All of these products are available in several colors so always a good idea to pick out the actual stones (particularly with granite) so you get something you like.
 
Last edited:
Be forewarned that Silestone (quartz) is not indestructible. My teenage son put it to the test by using a meat clever out of the knife block to cut cheese. Put a nice big chip in it! Also, don't let water sit on it too long. The water spots are difficult or impossible to remove. I have a ring from a pot lid that I can't remove.
 
We have quartzite, which isn't quartz but is a type of granite. It's gorgeous and we've done nothing to it in the 6 years we've had it except wipe it clean. Looks like new. It was kinda expensive, though. If I had to do it over again, I'd get Carrara marble. The countertop salespeople all say not to dare use that for your kitchen, but the heck with them. Many, many restaurants have Carrara marble counters and work surfaces. It's a classic look.
 
I have granite, a black with gold and green flecks and white cabinets. Mexican tile floors, 12 x 12, that are mostly a beige but because it is Mexican tile, the tiles vary from one to the other which I like. If I were doing dark cabinets, I would probably do a lighter counter colormaybe something with a little gold and brown streaking to match the cabinets. We have a small galley style kitchen, if I had a bigger counter area or an island, I would try to find a large piece so there are no cuts. Marble can also be beautiful. And around here, Chicago area, polished concrete countertops are popular. For flooring, it’s very personal. I used to have wood and changed to tile when we redid the kitchen about 8 years ago. Cork is good and a little softer but durable. I think high end linoleum is even coming back. I went to a high quality tile store and used their design services for my kitchen and bathrooms when we rehabbed them all about the same time, He really helped me come up with some great ideas for kitchen. back splash, showers and floors.
 
We upgraded to granite in our kitchen a few years ago. SO much better than the tile that was there before.
Our new house has formica, but it's in good shape so we'll probably wait a few years at least before thinking of upgrading it.
Same here. The home we now live in had just had the kitchen reno'd when we bought it. The laminate was brand new and OK looking and I just couldn't bring myself to trash it. We would like granite at some point though and it will increase the re-sale. :laughing: No granite was one of the reasons we went in with an offer under list.
We have quartzite, which isn't quartz but is a type of granite. It's gorgeous and we've done nothing to it in the 6 years we've had it except wipe it clean. Looks like new. It was kinda expensive, though. If I had to do it over again, I'd get Carrara marble. The countertop salespeople all say not to dare use that for your kitchen, but the heck with them. Many, many restaurants have Carrara marble counters and work surfaces. It's a classic look.
We visited a marble quarry when we were in Italy and it was fascinating!! Of course you should have what you want, but the salespeople aren't crazy. If any of our customers want to select natural marble, they have to sign in advance acknowledging the nature of the material and waiving warranty on cosmetic wear-and-tear. It scratches unbelievably easily and the glossy finish wears very fast.
 
We upgraded to granite in our kitchen a few years ago. SO much better than the tile that was there before.
Our new house has formica, but it's in good shape so we'll probably wait a few years at least before thinking of upgrading it.
Laminate is still a viable lower cost option and they're making it in much better colors these days.

Be forewarned that Silestone (quartz) is not indestructible. My teenage son put it to the test by using a meat clever out of the knife block to cut cheese. Put a nice big chip in it! Also, don't let water sit on it too long. The water spots are difficult or impossible to remove. I have a ring from a pot lid that I can't remove.
Bingo. A countertop, no matter how durable, is not a cutting board. It's a great way to ruin a knife and possibly the expensive countertop as well.
 
We have quartzite, which isn't quartz but is a type of granite. It's gorgeous and we've done nothing to it in the 6 years we've had it except wipe it clean. Looks like new. It was kinda expensive, though. If I had to do it over again, I'd get Carrara marble. The countertop salespeople all say not to dare use that for your kitchen, but the heck with them. Many, many restaurants have Carrara marble counters and work surfaces. It's a classic look.

My husband works in the tile industry. Every single kitchen or bath he's seen them use Carrera marble is etched and stained horribly after a few years. It's softer and more porous and absolutely SOAKS up pee and stains yellow, unable to be cleaned properly. Be forewarned if you have boys at home. Lol. They have gorgeous materials that mimic Carrera that are much more durable. Our plan is to do our master in it next year.

We've got light granite in the bathroom and kitchen, and I love it with my chocolate shaker cabinets. DH always like the latest and greatest trends since he sees it everyday, whereas I love a more classic look. To me, there is no more beautiful backsplash than a glass subway tile. We always have to majorly compromise since our styles are different.
 
Be forewarned that Silestone (quartz) is not indestructible. My teenage son put it to the test by using a meat clever out of the knife block to cut cheese. Put a nice big chip in it! Also, don't let water sit on it too long. The water spots are difficult or impossible to remove. I have a ring from a pot lid that I can't remove.
Yeah, common sense is don't use your countertop as a cutting board.
 
Did granite in 2012, had it treated. was told dont have to use a sealer and to only clean with soap and water, and the treated surface will last 20 year+. looks like the day it was installed
 

PixFuture Display Ad Tag




New Posts









Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE














DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top