Just Returned from the Poly: Lovely stay...but I have a concern

Tam1067

LOVES LOVES LOVES the Poly
Joined
Mar 29, 2006
Messages
3,545
We returned last night from our second Polynesian stay in as many years. Overall, it was a great experience.

Details: We arrived at about 11:30 a.m. on July 9, received our leis and were checked in quickly. I had requested Tokelau because I wanted a larger room in a central location with a balcony, and we got that request.

The room was lovely. The power strip appeared to be a bit pulled out, but beyond that, everything was nice.

Housekeeping was excellent, and actually an improvement over our stay last year when we were in Samoa. This time, the room was made up each day before we returned from the parks--one time by 11:00 a.m. We had extra towels each day without asking for them. Last year, we repeatedly had to call down to housekeeping and request more towels (we're 5 in the room), but this year, we were automatically given six bath towels and wash cloths each day. Toiletries were replaced each day, too, whereas last year they were not always.

Food and service at Kona, 'Ohana, and Captain Cook's were all good. Last year, the temporary location of Captain Cook's was not nearly as nice as the newly remodeled one (though the computer ordering can be confusing at first).

We ordered water, juice, and milk from Garden Grocer which saved us a lot of money.

I can say that we only had a few minor issues. First, as others have noted, the pool is crowded, and it's nearly impossible to find a chair in the afternoon.

Second, one afternoon, the garbage cans both inside and outside Captain Cook's were overflowing terribly. Another guest told my husband he had complained to some Captain Cook's CMs but that nothing had been done. They were still overflowing when we finished our lunch and left.

And the strangest of all was when we checked out. We called bell services for help with the luggage, and a bellman arrived within a few minutes. He took our bags down to the front, and my husband tipped him. Then, my husband tipped the valet who took our carry-ons to store while we went to the parks before we had to catch the bus to the airport. When DH went to the airline check-in desk to get boarding passes and check in the checked luggage for our flight, there were three employees there. One of them said to him, "We do accept gratuities here too."

DH was pretty irritated. First off, there were three employees there--are we now supposed to tip people who type in information on the computer? Do we tip someone who puts the airline stickers on the bags? We'd just spent over $30 in tips on people who actually were helping us, and it seems somewhat ridiculous to tip again. Also, I can't believe that a CM would be rude enough to ask for a tip in such a way. Does Disney now allow this, or am I behind the times here?

It's too bad that this one experience left a negative feeling to the end of our trip because otherwise, it was great.

Feel free to ask any questions about the resort--I'll do my best to answer.
 
I can't believe that a CM would be rude enough to ask for a tip in such a way. Does Disney now allow this, or am I behind the times here?

I think several of these types of services have been out sourced and this may be why this type of behavior is now seen.....
 
Thanks for sharing. I was happy to hear you enjoyed your stay at the Poly.
Just curious when you said it is nearly impossible to find a chair by the pool in the afternoon, do you mean right around noon, (lunch time) or later in the day? Just wondering as we will be going to the Poly next month. I know when we stay at the BCV, SAB can also fill up by early afternoon and it is often difficult to find a place to put your towel and shoes while you swim.

Thanks again for posting. :)
 

Quote: And the strangest of all was when we checked out. We called bell services for help with the luggage, and a bellman arrived within a few minutes. He took our bags down to the front, and my husband tipped him. Then, my husband tipped the valet who took our carry-ons to store while we went to the parks before we had to catch the bus to the airport. When DH went to the airline check-in desk to get boarding passes and check in the checked luggage for our flight, there were three employees there. One of them said to him, "We do accept gratuities here too."


I checked out of the Grand Floridian on 7/15. I had one very friendly, helpful bellman drive me and my bags directly over to the resort airline check in desk. He unloaded my bags at the counter and I was happy to tip him. Then as I began the airline process, the guy working the computer says to me "***** will be your skycap today." :confused3 So what, now these guys consider themselves to be skycaps?! Anyway, I took that as a hint that he expected to be tipped. I did give him a few dollars and the computer guy one. The third guy just stood there, not saying anything or doing anything. I gave him nothing. I'm not even sure what an appropriate tip amount is in that situation, but we were on our way home, and I had just about used all of the bills I had set aside for tipping on the trip. (I did have some 20's in my wallet, but that wasn't going to happen!! :rotfl: ) I know, generally speaking, it is customary to tip anyone who handles your bags, but the GF bellman had already done most of the work. All this guy had to do was to tag the bags and put them in the cages.

And as someone else posted, they are not Disney CM's.
 
I'd like to hear more about what to tip these guys. This has me almost not wanting to tip the RAC.
 
The people who man the airline check-in counters are not Disney employees. They are the same as the sky cabs who do curb side check-in at airports. At most US airports today, these people have a "required" tip for their services. Otherwise you can go into the airport and checkin at the airline counter. The same option would apply here also.
It is not wise to "stiff" the person who determines what flight your luggage will be on and where its final destination will be.
 
The people who man the airline check-in counters are not Disney employees. They are the same as the sky cabs who do curb side check-in at airports. At most US airports today, these people have a "required" tip for their services. Otherwise you can go into the airport and checkin at the airline counter. The same option would apply here also.
It is not wise to "stiff" the person who determines what flight your luggage will be on and where its final destination will be.

I think it's a bit odd 3 of them are wanting a tip though.
 
I never thought about tipping everybody at the RAC desk.

I tip the person giving me my boarding passes. I figured it went into a "tip jar" to be divided among all those working that shift.

Next time I'll ask if the tip is shared or not.

Ed
 
I think it's a bit odd 3 of them are wanting a tip though.

Not sure the OP meant all 3 were expecting a tip, just that 3 were standing there.

They probably are saying something because most people are not tipping, unlike they do at airports as drew64 said.

As stated they don't work for Disney, they are very much like the rental car agencies you see set up in hotels. They are allowed to be there but not employed by the hotel.
 
It is not wise to "stiff" the person who determines what flight your luggage will be on and where its final destination will be.


Yeah, my thoughts exactly!! But I guess, in my mind at the time, I just wasn't thinking of them as "skycaps," so I wasn't sure what to tip. I did give him something, hopefully an okay amount. (At any rate, I am happy to report that my bags all arrived at my destination :goodvibes and the resort airline checkin was very convenient for us.) Now that I know they are in fact considered skycaps for real, I can plan for it in the future. Thanks for clearing that up.
 
I too always just handed the tip to the one who gave me the boarding passes and figured they could divide it how they wanted to. I wouldn't tip all of the ones behind the desk individually.
 
I think it's a bit odd 3 of them are wanting a tip though.
I don't think "we accept tips, too" means each of the three of them expects a tip. "We" means the RAC personnel, overall - just like the SkyCaps at the airport, because, frankly, they're doing the same work (which means they're the ones tagging your luggage for, ideally, your home airport ;))
 
Yeah handing the money to the one who gives you the pass makes sense, and they can divide it up or whatever. That makes it easy and less awkward
definitely.
 
I too always just handed the tip to the one who gave me the boarding passes and figured they could divide it how they wanted to. I wouldn't tip all of the ones behind the desk individually.

Boy, flying is getting more and more expensive!!! :rotfl:
 
Reading these posts gave me an "Ah Ha" moment. If I was checking in at the airport I would be tipping both the hotel Bellman and the Skycaps. Guess airport hotel check-in should be no different. However, I would not normally tip the person giving me my boarding pass. I'll be keeping it in mind when we travel to the world in Dec.
 
As others have said, I do not thinkk most WDW guests realize that the RAC staff are not Disney employees. They are just like airport skycaps, who you would tip.
I plan on giving one tip to the RAC staff to divide how they see fit.
 
Wow, this is good information to know (the RAC folks not being Disney employees but actually 'Skycaps'). August will be my first time using RAC at the Poly. I use Skycaps pretty extensively at the airports and am used to tipping them.

Good thing I found this out now so I can work it into the trip budget!
 
Thanks for sharing. I was happy to hear you enjoyed your stay at the Poly.
Just curious when you said it is nearly impossible to find a chair by the pool in the afternoon, do you mean right around noon, (lunch time) or later in the day? Just wondering as we will be going to the Poly next month. I know when we stay at the BCV, SAB can also fill up by early afternoon and it is often difficult to find a place to put your towel and shoes while you swim.

Thanks again for posting. :)

We were generally at the pool at about 2:00 or 3:00 in the afternoon. I'm not sure how crowded it was about noon, but there always seemed to be lots of people there.
 


Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE








DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom