Jodi Arias Trial Part 8 EXTREME CRUELTY: PROVEN

Penalty phase...what will the jury decide? (1 day poll!)

  • Death

  • Life (judge will sentence within 60 days, LWOP or Parole in 25 years)

  • No unanimous decision...new penalty phase jury will be empaneled.


Results are only viewable after voting.
Good night my friends. Going to stop watching all coverage for tonight. See you in the morning.
 
I don't think Travis was 100% innocent. I think he was very guilty - guilty of being a fool who let his sex drive think for him. There is too much evidence that she stalked him for me to believe otherwise.

I think those of us who know somebody like her (and I do, although not to her extent - at least not thus far) are terrified by the fact that we know this could happen to somebody we know. Not everybody agrees with the death penalty, and I'm guessing you don't. I do, particularly in a case as savage as this one. It was proven beyond a shadow of a doubt that this was premeditated - that completely does away with any question for me that she may reacted in the way you described. JMHO

::yes::
 
I too, as much as I am sad for Travis's family, think this jury did a decent job. I'm just a little surprised that those who were going for the death penalty could not be talked down to life. I imagine that would be easier than trying to talk someone into the death penalty.

And in all honesty we are all thinking that the hold out was someone who could not vote for death..but what if the hold out was the other way? What if one person would not change their vote to life?

If I had been on the jury, I would have been willing to agree with LWOP, but I'm not sure they had that option. If I understand correctly, Life would have left it up to the judge whether she got LWOP or 25 years. I couldn't have voted that way knowing the judge might give her only 25 years.

That said, I respect the jury and the fact that they did what they felt they had to do. Unlike the CA jury, they took their responsibility seriously and found her guilty of 1st degree murder.
 

horseshowmom, I think you and I could stay up all night at a slumber party talking about our respective BPD persons. ::yes:: We "get" the Jodi type all too well.:thumbsup2 :hug:
I know people with BPD and I think they get a terrible rap. They are often confused with sociopaths, which I think is more Jodi's MO. A lot of folks with BPD couldn't and wouldn't hurt a fly.
 
horseshowmom, I think you and I could stay up all night at a slumber party talking about our respective BPD persons. ::yes:: We "get" the Jodi type all too well.:thumbsup2 :hug: I agree. EXCEPT...it would have been DP or "Life", and the judge decides with or without parole at sentencing a month or two later. I think if it was between DP and LWOP it may have been easier, and that they would have decided on "LWOP."

I know, I keep hoping that if it is life, it's LWOP so I keep typing what I want instead of what the law is. I think you are right about if the choice was LWOP it would have been easier to get the jurors to agree.
 
I too, as much as I am sad for Travis's family, think this jury did a decent job. I'm just a little surprised that those who were going for the death penalty could not be talked down to life. I imagine that would be easier than trying to talk someone into the death penalty.

And in all honesty we are all thinking that the hold out was someone who could not vote for death..but what if the hold out was the other way? What if one person would not change their vote to life?

The jury will now go and see the things they never heard or saw. And I am sure that will make them feel sick. I would love to know what they saw differently from one another. I heard Jodi's mom is upset. But now Nurmi and Willmont can walk away and she will be appointed another set of attorney's
 
And on a lighter note...

Look at how much more bandwidth we get to waste!! NBW 4ever! ;)

C'mon guys, it's going to end the way it is suppose to, it just going to take a while longer.
 
The jury will now go and see the things they never heard or saw. And I am sure that will make them feel sick. I would love to know what they saw differently from one another. I heard Jodi's mom is upset. But now Nurmi and Willmont can walk away and she will be appointed another set of attorney's

So no reclinating, finger-sniffing, crazy socks, "bald spots", or desalting for the next trial? What will hWild talk about? :confused3 ;)
 
This jury really did let this family down, and I truly think the judge knows it too because of her emotions that sort of came threw her voice.

My only hope now is that the new jury will also hear the interviews that she gave. That may just be enough to push them over the edge because her true colors came out in the latest one.

My heart just breaks for the Alexander family. :sad1: They have been through so much! :mad:
 
Question for the "legal eagles". IF the next jury is unable to make a unanimous decision, I understand the sentence can be decided by the judge. Question, is this correct and if so, can the judge impose death?

My heart breaks for the Alexander family. I'm sure they really want to put this behind them and focus on their lives just as Travis would have wanted them to.
 
I know, I keep hoping that if it is life, it's LWOP so I keep typing what I want instead of what the law is. I think you are right about if the choice was LWOP it would have been easier to get the jurors to agree.

If she got LWOP it is better than knowing she may walk in 20 yrs.
 
horseshowmom, I think you and I could stay up all night at a slumber party talking about our respective BPD persons. ::yes:: We "get" the Jodi type all too well.:thumbsup2 :hug: I agree.

Absolutely, sharing horror stories, I suspect. ;)

EXCEPT...it would have been DP or "Life", and the judge decides with or without parole at sentencing a month or two later. I think if it was between DP and LWOP it may have been easier, and that they would have decided on "LWOP."

I see that we were posting about this issue at the same time. And, yes, that's what makes all the difference (at least to me).
 
And on a lighter note...

Look at how much more bandwidth we get to waste!! NBW 4ever! ;)

C'mon guys, it's going to end the way it is suppose to, it just going to take a while longer.

Ha! I was thinking of this earlier. The way it's going, we could be wasting bandwith (notoriously) throughout the end of Summer and possibly into Fall! :teeth: :rotfl:

On the serious side though, in the end, she'll end up with life w/parole at the very least no matter what happens next time.
 
Question for the "legal eagles". IF the next jury is unable to make a unanimous decision, I understand the sentence can be decided by the judge. Question, is this correct and if so, can the judge impose death?

My heart breaks for the Alexander family. I'm sure they really want to put this behind them and focus on their lives just as Travis would have wanted them to.

I am not a legal eagle, but I do know the judge can not sentence her to death only life either with or without parole.
 
So no reclinating, finger-sniffing, crazy socks, "bald spots", or desalting for the next trial? What will hWild talk about? :confused3 ;)

Make up something new. But Jodi's life still hangs in the balance. She still does not know what will happen. Hopefully Joe Arpio will stand by his words and no more interviews.
 
Ha! I was thinking of this earlier. The way it's going, we could be wasting bandwith (notoriously) throughout the end of Summer and possibly into Fall! :teeth: :rotfl:

On the serious side though, in the end, she'll end up with life w/parole at the very least no matter what happens next time.

The thread that never dies.......:lmao:
 
Make up something new. But Jodi's life still hangs in the balance. She still does not know what will happen. Hopefully Joe Arpio will stand by his words and no more interviews.

Speaking of the interviews, can JM use those during the next penalty phase?
 











Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE








DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom