Actually, what would be neater than that would be the Villas at
Castaway Cay..
I can never see them doing that, I think there is more of a chance of the
DVC DCL than Castaway Cay. There might be enough acreage to physically do it, but there would be way too many operation limitations. First of all, the only way to get there would be by boat, or small charter plane (if they opened the runway again.) Beyond the high cost of getting there, the maintenance dues would be crazy (as crazy as DCL), as everything (equipment, supplies, and CM's) would have to be shipped in. As a matter of fact, you'd also be paying to build accommodations for the cast members, and support their room and board through dues. The island generates their fresh water from seawater through reverse osmosis, and the cost of doing that to a level that would support a resort would be prohibitive. As would dealing with sewage and wastewater. Finally, the bugs on the island are so bad in the evening; you wouldn't be able to leave your room after 5pm (which is why the ships always leave before sunset).
Not to mention, IMHO, it's a nice place to visit for a day, but I would be bored out of my skull after about 3! I'm not a big fan of the Caribbean anyway, but I would much rather have them build a DVC resort at an established location such as St. John, Playa Del Carmen, or even Puerto Rico, where there is more to see and do.
BTW, here is a link to a cool aerial photo of Castaway Cay.
http://maps.yahoo.com/;_ylc=X3oDMTE...**=h&trf=0&lon=-77.532299&lat=26.083729&mag=3
I wonder which ship that is?