Is this child abuse/neglect and...

tmarquez

DIS Veteran
Joined
May 6, 2003
Messages
1,446
...what would you do?

Sorry, this might be kind of long. First I want to start out by saying I think this is definately neglect (if not abuse) but since I'm close to the situation I want to be sure I'm not just mad at these people.

The child is 5. She is very skinny and sickly looking all the time. She has a chronic cough, black circles under her eyes, bad teeth and an all around unhealthy look. I don't know if she has some sort of health problem because her parents do not take her to the doctors.

Her mom lives in the house about 1/3 of the week. Her dad works long hours. She stays mostly with her 12 year old sister.

There have been MANY times when she comes to my house to play with DD and when it is time for her to go home, there is nobody at her house. The parents ALWAYS blame the 12yo, saying she was supossed to be home. When this happens we usually dress her in DD's clothes and shoes (which are too big) and bring her with us. She is never dressed appropriately for the weather.

On the weekends she eats all of her meals at our house. I honestly don't know if she has dinner on weeknights or not. She lies and is very manipulative, and definately has problems due to her family life.

I also suspect at least the mom of drug use.

I'm pretty sure they have been reported to DCF before, the whole neighborhood apparently pretty much watched because the police escorted the social worker to the house. Not sure who reported, maybe the school. Things got slighty better right after this, but now they are right back to where they were.

I'm a mandatory reporter. But I am VERY afraid to report these parents because they have retaliated against other neighbors for dumb little things with violence and property damage. The victims were afraid to report this to the police.

This might sound bad (selfish), but I'm exhausted from trying to almost raise this little girl. I wanted 1 kid, now it seems like I have 2 (and 1 with big problems). It's affecting the quality of my life with my own family. What would you do?
 
To me, it sounds like they neglect her. And a 12 year old cannot be responsible for a younger sibling.

Report them.
 

I would call too.

Good for you for taking care of that little girl!

There is a boy that I've practically raised for the past 4 yrs. At first I was irritated about it but the more I hear of his situation (not nearly as bad as yours) I've changed my thinking and have accepted him as part of the family when he's here. He jokingly calls me "mom" now and I actually like it!;)

Keep loving on that little girl! She needs it! Someday she might come back and say you were the reason she's okay today!:thumbsup2
 
call and request anonymity. continue to take care of her if she remains in the home. I feel for the 12yo too.
 
You are a mandatory reporter of these types of concerns. I am sure there is a way where you can stress to the authorities that your name and address on the complaint be left out of it. Good luck, you are doing the right thing for this helpless child because no one else will.
 
Definitely call, but I'd stress anonymity for your and your family's safety. :(
 
I would see if the DFS can't pick her up at school. so she doesn't even have to go home.
 
Can't you report anonymously? The family doesn't have the right to know who reported them.

In any case--it is not up to us to determine if it is abuse/neglect--but it does sound like it could be and I would report it.
 
If they have been reported in the past and the situation is like you describe, wouldn't they be in the system already? If its failing them now, what good would reporting them again do? I'm not saying don't but it sounds like doing it may not really change anything.
 
I would definitely call anonymously. It's really horrible that kids suffer for having parents who are idiots. She's only 5...she can't possibly be able to look out for herself and a 12 year old shouldn't be expected to take care of younger sibling either. That's not only neglectful, it's dangerous.
 
My 2 cents, I would go to a public phone and make multiple reports to multiple organizations, the school, the local police & child services. Also, type at least one unsigned letter and mail it to multiple organizations from an zip that is not your own and keep a copy. This way you are doing your legal obligation without endangering your family and if you ever have to show proof, you have a copy of the letter that at least one on the institutions will keep in their file. Chances are if you make multiple reports at least one will stick.

Also, does your DA office have anyone in particular who handles all the child abuse cases in your area? Most do. If you find this person he, or more likely she, will make sure it gets handled properly.

Poor kid:sad1:
 
Yes call. Likely the parents got a second chance and thus got her back, another complaint and investigation could be just the thing needed to make more drastic and longer term changes.
 
I would definitely call anonymously. It's really horrible that kids suffer for having parents who are idiots. She's only 5...she can't possibly be able to look out for herself and a 12 year old shouldn't be expected to take care of younger sibling either. That's not only neglectful, it's dangerous.

Thats not really true, some 12 year oldsare mature enough and old enough to care for a sibling. I have a 12 year old and while she isn't responsible for my younger dses more of the time I am, i have counted on her for help, and its a far cry from neglectful and dangerous. In the situation with the OP, it sounds like there are other things going on as well, however I just wanted to say that in different situations there is absolutely nothing wrong with a 12 year old taking care of a younger sibling or a parent relying on that kind of help.
 








Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE








DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom