Il Mulino or Tutto Italia?

[kathyg]

I don't know if many of you have been to both, but if you have, which do you prefer?

Frankly, I think they are both overpriced for what they offer. While Alfredo's wasn't terrific, I still found their food decent and affordable. I was blown away by the prices at both Il Mulino and Tutto Italia. But being an Italian, I need my fix. So which will it be?

 

[Tiffany]

I don't know if many of you have been to both, but if you have, which do you prefer?

Frankly, I think they are both overpriced for what they offer. While Alfredo's wasn't terrific, I still found their food decent and affordable. I was blown away by the prices at both Il Mulino and Tutto Italia. But being an Italian, I need my fix. So which will it be?

We have had dinner at both and perfer Il Mulino as we found the menu, service and atmosphare to be more upscale then Tutto's. Not sure I would go back to Tutto's now that we have found Il Mulino's.

 

[TigerKat]

While we haven't eaten at either we talked to quite a few people while we were there (we ate at Blue Zoo) who had eaten at Il Mulino and raved about it. We saw the menus at both and I think while both are quite expensive you'll get more bang for your buck at Il Mulino. We spent more at Blue Zoo than any other restaurant and it was by far the best meal of our trip!

 

[BCV23]

We haven't tried Il Mulino yet but have already had dinner three times at Tutto Italia since it opened this Fall.

It is a huge improvement on Alfredo's IMO. The food is delicious and quite different from your favorite neighborhood Italian restaurant.

Service has been great,too. Bad service at Alfredo's was the reason we stopped going there some years ago.

And the tables less crowded than they were. It's possible to enjoy the ambiance of the restaurant again as it was in the early days of Epcot.

I agree the prices are high but at least we can use our DDE or DDP(when we have that) or both at Tutto's. I don't think there is even an AP discount at Il Mulino?