My only complaint about
DCL is the pricing. We did the Alaska cruise in 2014 with DCL and actually toyed with trying another cruise line. At the end we decided we'd rather stick with DCL since the excursions were important to us and we had Platinum status. I also pointed out to DH that we had been on one RCL and one Carnival cruise before trying DCL and neither of us were remotely interested in cruises after the experience. We just went because other family members were going. Our first DCL cruise was a DVC member cruise and there was no going back after that. We did 2 DVC member cruises and realized how ridiculous the pricing was so we stopped doing those but are still pretty loyal to DCL.
DH and I have both discussed trying to get status on another cruise line. We are willing to give Celebrity a whirl since I always hear good things. However, we keep booking DCL each year LOL
Me too! We just completed our 18th
Disney Cruise last month. We also never get off the ship on the Caribbean cruises unless I need to pick up a new inhaler in the Bahamas with no prescription at the pharmacy or a new set of bamboo sheets at Cariloha
Paying DCL with Disney GCs is where we can justify some of the cost as well as on board booking. We are platinum with DCL so we will get opening day pricing. I already know that we will get 10% off for booking on board and a stateroom credit and just have choose our future date. My TA is going to kick in a stateroom credit as well. Then, we are going to get 5x in UR because the entire cruise will be paid using Disney GCs. Chase and Amex will have some offer that will get me discounted Disney GCs as well so that will be an additional savings. I do imagine that we may start trying out Celebrity for short cruises and begin working our way towards status. None the less, we still have every intention of doing the next 3 Maiden Voyages with DCL and any brand new itinerary that piques our interest.
I'll chime in with the other perspective. I suppose if bargain hunting is the motivation, then DCL would not be worth it. They are expensive. Value, on the other hand, is something that is very subjective and what is important and worth the cost to one person, may not be worth it to another. To me, the value is with DCL. When I compare our experience on RCL and Carnival to any of our DCL cruises then DCL wins hands down, no contest. The food was better, the service was laughably waaay better, the ship was cleaner on the inside and outside etc. But that still is not what has me hooked with DCL. Its the people. The fellow cruisers and the staff. On our very first Disney cruise which was the DVC member cruise in 2010. A year before that cruise we were getting to know our fellow cruisers here on the DIS in the cruise meets thread. We had a blast and by the time we boarded the ship we had friends that we linked dining with and got to know better throughout the cruise. The following year, we did it again and added even more amazing people to our group. There is now a group of about 40 of us that regularly keep in touch on the "social media site that shall not be named". Of that group, 20-30 of us regularly cruise together and meet up in WDW, or DLR and there's one other couple that has done ABDs with us. We are all good friends and have been there for each other IRL not just on fun vacations. Those amazing people would simply not be in my life if we had chosen to cruise on a less expensive cruise line. I can't put a price tag on that.