I use 3 rolls for wrapping almost exclusively now:My father and grandmother were both artists and I have a tad of the gene, but don't really have time to use it anymore, so wrapping gifts is my outlet. I am very picky about my paper, coordinating it and I do nice ribbons (sometimes just tulle) and add little goodies, depending on the paper. This year the papers are various plaids and the goodies are cinnamon sticks, copper ornaments, and fresh holly.
Brown mailing paper
A roll of white butcher's paper
The hugest roll of heavy Mylar I ever seen in life. Bought it in the '80's and it's first use was to wrap the walls of my then brownstone foyer entrance in it and then decorate the space with white painted branches and baskets of dried angel's breath and white lights. Was a fantastic entry way and detracted from the lack of furniture in the L/R, LOL.
All can be customised with stamps, free form acrylic or water paints and are easy to wrap with the exception of the Mylar which takes way more work to make square corners.