In my experience, they are sticklers and do not use the "close enough" kind of attitude.
That's because the "Close Enough" attitude can get a CM fired.
They do measure with shoes *unless* the shoes look really really thick, in which case they measure without.
We were at DW last week. I witnessed at several rides in several parks CMs asking children to remove shoes to measure height.
Shoes are required at all times by all Guests. CMs may NOT, under any circumstances, ask a Guest to remove their shoes.
Now, if a Guest is wearing shoes that obviously don't belong to them or are obviously padded or heightened, then the CM can get a leader involved... but no, they can't tell a Guest to take their shoes off.
EDIT: Speaking as a parent, if a CM ever told me to remove my son's shoes, I'd
politely refuse and ask to speak to that CM's leader. But that's just me.
I do wish they'd just have a definitive measurer at Guest Relations and then give the kid a wristband with different colors for different height ranges (then each CM could just be trained what color wristbands are allowed/not allowed on that attraction).
As previously stated, we tried that.
OT question, but what about "little people" who are adults? What if they aren't 40" or 44" or 48"?
The height requirements apply to all guests, regardless of age. And yes, I've had this happen to me on two separate occasions (one was an adult Little Person, and one was a fellow CM who was an amputee. Neither one rode, and yes, it was awkward; the CM, who had just started her college program, even told me that she would quit her job and go back home if she couldn't ride the attractions).
A CM on another thread said that a guest once produced a letter from their Doctor proving that their kid was 40".
I had someone try that with me, actually -- and I had just checked the height stick's calibration (we do that each and every morning. The problem is that some of our Maintenance workers like to shrug and mutter "eh, close enough." I
never let them get away with that and always double-checked their work.). The child was a full two inches short -- at least. I told the Guest, "If your doctor thinks he's 40 inches tall, you might want to think about getting another Doctor."
Imagine this scenario: Parents cheat the system by switching a colored bracelet, bringing a doctor's note, pitching a stinkin' fit, or producing an Act of Congress to allow their child to ride something he/she is not really tall enough for. Child falls out or otherwise gets injured. Do parents say, "oops, my bad!" No, they will sue Disney for whatever they can get, and the argument will probably be, "They should have known my child was not tall enough."
Or, "They should have been more diligent in keeping my family safe."
You'd be surprised (or perhaps not) what I've seen Guests say -- and do -- to get their kids on the rides. I understand that for many Guests, a visit to WDW can be a once-in-a-lifetime trip, and that they want their families to experience as much as possible.
I get that -- I really, honestly do. But a trip to the emergency room can ruin the Disney magic pretty quickly.
The two biggest stresses of a CM's day are FastPass and Height Requirements. Thank God I only work at attractions now that have neither.
