I get a fresh free range no hormone/antibiotic naturally fed (did I forget anything?

) pre-brined bird from Trader Joes and simply stuff it with aromatics (as opposed to actual stuffing). The aromatics I usually use are garlic, lemon, apple, rosmary, thyme, sage, and an cinamon stick. I rub the skin down with canola oil and sprinkle with salt and pepper.
Then I use the Alton Brown method of cooking it un-covered at 500 for 20 minutes or so to get the skin all brown and crispy, then lowering the temp, covering the breast with tin foil and letting it coast until it's done. I don't do breast down since it is brined, but I do hear it is recommended for non-brined birds. Just be aware that it won't look as nice, so if table presentation of the turky is important to you, you'll want to do it breast side up, and just cover the breast with foil instead.
Anyway, I did this last year at it was THE BEST TURKEY I'VE EVER HAD. And I don't just say this because I'm the one that made it, it was really yummy! So I'm doing it the exact same way this year to see if it was just a lucky fluke or if I'm on to something here!
And the best thing is that it's easy. Between cleaning, stuffing, tieing up, putting on the oil/salt/pepper and getting it in the oven is maybe 10 minutes, and that's cuz I spend so much time cleaning it.
ETA: Another tip is to not get a bird that is too big. Anything over 18 pounds is likely an older bird and can be tough. Also it can be harder to get it to cook right, often by the time the dark meat is done the breast meat is toast. If a smaller bird won't be enough to feed your crew, then you can just get an extra breast or roast two smaller birds. The advantage to two is that you then get double the drumsticks and wings, making your guests happier!
If you don't have the room for two birds in your oven, you can make one of your turkeys on a charcoal grill (gas grills work too)! My family has done this for years and it gives it a wonderfully, light smokey flavor. My brother did this last year, did a full turkey on the Weber and did a breast in the oven. This left lots of room for the side dishes too.
Alternatly, you can make the turkey the day before and just heat it up on T-day. My aunt did this after under cooking the bird one year. By cooking it the day before it gives her more time to make sure it's done right, AND it gives her more room in her oven for all the sides that she makes the day of.