We've stayed at CBR several times and had wonderful experiences! We also have stayed at Pop, and it's "okay"... just okay. Our upcoming trip will be at Pop, not because it's where we would prefer to stay, but because after Hurricane Katrina swooped in and affected us, and our daughter got married, we just don't have the funds to stay anywhere else if we want to go to Disney for our anniversary! If cost is a major factor to you, Pop is your place. Likewise, if all you do at the resort is sleep, and you plan to be in the parks most of the time, it's a good choice. IMO, it's the best of the value resorts. However, for a honeymoon, I can't imagine you would be spending minimal time in the room, and the rooms at Pop just wouldn't feel like a honeymoon to me. If you can go a little higher, you can't go wrong with CBR or even Coronado. I've heard very good things about it too. That's where my brother will be staying when we renew our vows in December. HTH! ~Ev