Our church uses Great Lakes Scrip.
Our Church decided to stock more commonly used scrip cards, and they are for sale every Sunday morning between services. The downside on this - there was a huge cash outlay to get the "store" stocked up. I am guessing we have $7000 or so in cards stocked. We stock about 50 different cards.
There is one local grocery store that offers a similar program, and the person in charge of SCRIP at church gets those directly from the store.
Our church orders scrip once a week in the fall through spring, and every other week in the summer.
Very few of our members are linked into presto pay for the purpose of ordering ScripNow or to just order their GC's. I don't think anyone has done the "mobile" app, most likely, I'll be the one to be the first on that one. Unfortunately - I just have not been shopping for fun stuff, as I have not been working. I start a new job soon - so that will give me a little more discretionary income, and I will most likely participate with the mobile app.
My DD had been in a private sports club a few years ago - and the monies "earned" by participation in SCRIP went directly to offset her club expenses, and the club requirement was that all orders needed to be paid through presto pay.
I LOVE ScripNow! My DD is now in college, renting a house, and I am easily able to order her scrip - and then just have her print it out at her house when she goes shopping or out to eat. Or - if I am feeling generous - I'll just send her an ITunes e-card because I want to.
People will either buy into the program, or not.
If you do this as a PTO/PTA fundraiser, and are unsure how well it is going to go over - can I suggest that you do it on a limited basis this year, perhaps in late October, through November and early December. Have a limited number of shipping dates - to minimize that expense.
Also - from a school/liability perspective, have a plan in place so that the GC's do not get sent home with the kids.
One nice thing about Kohl's cards from Scrip they can be used to pay your Kohls Charge bill. (You have to do this in the store.) So - to me, this is a win-win no-brainer.
I've never done a reloadable card, I just do not get the point. From what I understand, it isn't an "instant" transaction like the SCRIPNOW is, it can only be done on a day when the SCRIP office is open.
Just my random thoughts...