Help!! Disappointing Progress Report

My first thought was that maybe it was a typing error. I'm a teacher and I know that our report card system can be very touchy when it comes to clicking on the proper mark and sometimes you don't realize that you've clicked on the wrong mark until after the fact. I always double-check before submitting them for that exact reason. If his grade was really an F I think the teacher should have given you a heads-up. That's a drastic change in marks and she should have known it would cause concern. Also, I know it's difficult because it's your son, but keep in mind that this is only 1 mark on 1 progress report in the first grade. It doesn't mean he is doomed for the rest of his scholastic career. There are so many different grading systems out there and so much of marking/grading is subjective that at this early age, unless it's an obvious/consistent problem, I wouldn't spend too much time stressing about it. Your son will pick-up on it and it might make him anxious. I have seen too many really young kids obsessing about whether they get an A or a B on a report card and the only reason they are made to feel like it's so important is because that's how they were trained by their parents to think. That's not to say that at some point making an A versus a B doesn't become important, but I just don't think it's necessary to have kids as young as 5 or 6 stressing about these things. Just my $.02.
 
First off, as a teacher and a mother, I see red flags that a first grader has grades on his report card at all. Kids this young should not be graded. You should be getting reports on what he's learned and what he is finding challenging. The fact that you have percentages when talking about a six year old is scary :scared1: .

When I was teaching, I would always alert parents if the kid was heading towards an F in something. They got weekly graded papers and a note if things weren't going well. Of course, these kids were in fourth grade. The fact that your son's teacher says she grades things when she has time is awful. Is it a private school? If so, you are not getting your money's worth. I taught in public schools in a good district and something like that would have cost me my job :teacher: .
 
This is very strange to me. Each Friday my kids (grades K, 1, 4) bring home a "Friday Folder." Each Friday folder has a list of all the papers that should be in the folder. All their graded papers from that week are in the folder. This includes homework, classwork and tests. In addition, my 4th grader has a "homework book" in which she has to write her assignments. The younger 2 have a homework folder in which they bring home their assignments. The teacher always gives out a "schedule" when they start a new "unit" which includes dates for quizzes and tests and outlines on what they will be quizzed/tested. (not so much the kinder, they don't really "test.") I don't know whether it is a teacher issue, or a classroom size issue, but I would expect to know much sooner if my "A" student were earning "F's"
 
Hi all! Thank you for all your helpful suggestions. I called the teacher the morning after receiving the progress report and she promptly called me back. She admitted to not sending home any graded papers and was very apologetic. She told me about two tests that he did not do well on. One he halfway finished and one he barely started on because he wanted to doodle on the back of the paper. She said she only allows them to doodle on the back of their paper after they finish their tests. Well, my child doesn't have a lot of self control when it comes to putting necessary things over fun things(we are constantly working on it) so I told him no more doodling on the back of test papers period. She apologized for not giving me a heads up on the progress report and said that she wanted it to be more of a wake up call for him. I asked what I could do from home and she said to just practice with him. I asked her if she thought he was comprehending everything and she said yes, that he was one of the brightest kids in class and that he has plenty of time to pull the grade back up to an A. I asked if there is any extra work he can do to help and she said that if it gets down to the last week and his grade is still not up to a good grade she would give him extra work to do. As for my son he has realized what an F means in our house. He has been banned from the computer, tv and any other fun activity in our home(except for reading) until I receive a graded math test with an A on it. I have also reiterated no doodling at all on tests. I felt a little better after talking to her but I still feel kind of out of the loop per se. I hope I'm going to be filled in more on how he is doing on more of a daily basis. I certainly don't want to wait until his report card. I thought about sending letters once a week inquiring about how he is doing. What does everybody think? Any other suggestions?
 

I used to do this with my SD (ex's daughter) She was an unmotivated student (lot's of other issues, but that is a whole new post!) We would communicate with the teacher via email. She would send us a weekly progress report about behavior and incomplete classwork/homework. Maybe a brief email "update" on Fridays would help.
 
Hi all! Thank you for all your helpful suggestions. I called the teacher the morning after receiving the progress report and she promptly called me back. She admitted to not sending home any graded papers and was very apologetic. She told me about two tests that he did not do well on. One he halfway finished and one he barely started on because he wanted to doodle on the back of the paper. She said she only allows them to doodle on the back of their paper after they finish their tests. Well, my child doesn't have a lot of self control when it comes to putting necessary things over fun things(we are constantly working on it) so I told him no more doodling on the back of test papers period. She apologized for not giving me a heads up on the progress report and said that she wanted it to be more of a wake up call for him. I asked what I could do from home and she said to just practice with him. I asked her if she thought he was comprehending everything and she said yes, that he was one of the brightest kids in class and that he has plenty of time to pull the grade back up to an A. I asked if there is any extra work he can do to help and she said that if it gets down to the last week and his grade is still not up to a good grade she would give him extra work to do. As for my son he has realized what an F means in our house. He has been banned from the computer, tv and any other fun activity in our home(except for reading) until I receive a graded math test with an A on it. I have also reiterated no doodling at all on tests. I felt a little better after talking to her but I still feel kind of out of the loop per se. I hope I'm going to be filled in more on how he is doing on more of a daily basis. I certainly don't want to wait until his report card. I thought about sending letters once a week inquiring about how he is doing. What does everybody think? Any other suggestions?

Is this your only child in school? I'm just wondering if this is school policy (grading policy, parent/teacher communication, etc.) or just the way this teacher handles her classroom.

How often do you receive report cards. Here, elementary is every 10 weeks, middle and high school are every 6 weeks. I think waiting until, " it gets down to the last week and his grade is still not up to a good grade she would give him extra work to do," is too long. Could she send you one half-way between marking periods? Our middle and high school are required to send one if the child is in danger of failing and some teachers send one for all their students, regardless of their grade.

Also, it shouldn't just be about his "grade," not at any age, but especially this young. The focus should be on learning, working to the best of his ability and taking pride in his work.

Grades don't always reflect what a child knows and understands... for a any number of reasons, poor test takers (test anxiety), verbal vs written work, a simple mistake on a "fill in the bubble" sheet, etc. However, it is the main system used to measure a child's knowledge, strength and weakness. Grades can also determine future placement or privileges.

At this age, I wouldn't focus on the "F" (in and of itself.) What if, one day he receives an "F" because he truly doesn't understand the material or concept... nothing good can come from making a child feel bad about him/herself. I would stress the importance of always doing his best. It's really all we can ask of anyone.
 
I want you to know that developmentally it is not all that unusual for a first grader to skip problems, doodle, look around, etc. In my opinion, the teacher should have redirected him to get it finished. It sounds like she might just be sitting at her desk. :confused3 She is not finding out how much math he knows. Instead she could have written a note about his classroom habits or at least let you know why he got an F. Anyway, at least you don't have to worry about his math skills.
 
Just an update....My son had family reading night/book fair at his school last night. I spoke to his teacher and she said he is doing better with his classwork and is very bright. She then said most of his problems came from being very disorganized and being unable to finish one task before beginning another. She asked if he had any of these problems at home. Son has always been very active and has a hard time concentrating/focusing on things and is very impulsive, etc. My husband checked out warning signs for add and he has all 9 they listed. The teacher suggested testing for add/adhd at our discretion. Has anyone else had children tested? I'm not sure what to expect. If he is diagnosed I'm not that keen on medication. My oldest brother has pretty severe add/adhd and I know what he has struggled with in life. My husband is taking it pretty hard and although I've suspected our son might have this my husband is in complete denial. I certainly want to make sure he properly diagnosed and is not just an active child. But my main goal is that he gets every opportunity to have a good education. Should a child this young be tested? Am I overexaggerating things in my mind? :confused:
 
I can give you some perspective as a teacher and a parent.

There are definitely some kids who benefit from medicine. In second grade I had one who could just not do a thing academically without it. He would be under desks and out of control without it. But, I remember one specific case where the mom wanted to try going without. The little boy did fine. Yes, I had to redirect him and help with organization, but for the most part, in my classroom he was okA
 
I can give you some perspective as a teacher and a parent.

There are definitely some kids who benefit from medicine. In second grade I had one who could just not do a thing academically without it. He would be under desks and out of control without it. But, I remember one specific boy where the mom wanted to try going without. The little boy did fine. Yes, I had to redirect him and help with organization, but for the most part, in my classroom he was okay without it. His prior teacher was adamant he needed it. Her classroom was much more traditional than mine. Now, I bet as he got older and was sitting for longer periods of time, he would probably need it. I was very upfront with his mom about this, and the fact that other kids would probably notice me redirecting, etc. She was okay with this because she did not want him on meds so young. I guess my point is some teachers can work with mild cases of ADD/ADHD, while others are much more rigid.

As a parent... I would bet my son has ADD. His organization is terrible, and he often forgets to turn in papers. He is in third grade and has made all A's. He is so smart that once he recreated a worksheet he had forgotten at school. I don't see the point in having him tested or put on medicine when he is succeeding. If he was failing and miserable, I would think differently. I do anticipate middle school and lockers being a disaster. If we don't see improvement in 5th grade, I will go through the testing, etc.

I'm not sure how to help with your DH. If he does end up needing meds and he sees the positive difference, that should help. I don't think it could hurt going through the testing so you know if is ADD or not. There are other things you can try before medicine if it is not a severe case.

Good luck!
 

New Posts


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom