A few things to point out
1st, if your paying cash on delivery- chances are high that your paying more than your neighbor who pre-bought or budget. Last year, cash price here, reached 2.76 a gallon.
2nd if your not using the same company regularly- your may have a problem if you have a problem with your furnance, unless you have a furnace man whose independent near you. Most oil/heating companies will not offer you 24 hour emergency service if your not an oil company...just a FYI
the difference between a budget and a pre-buy at least here, is as follows
You call and tell them you will need X gallons per winter, we'll use me and my company as an example, you can see the difference in the end. (these are last years figures, as not many companies here are doing a budget with a guarantee'd rate)
budget plan
500 gallons, x 2.24 per gallon $1120.00
Budget / 8 months $ 140.00 per month
Pre-buy plan
500 gallons x 2.08 per gallon $1040.00
Difference- $80.00
Another difference, budget at this company payments start oct 1st, pre-buy is due paid in full by august 31st. That might be a factor for some people...
In my case, its not "that much" of a savings, but for some of these houses that use upwards of 1,000's of gallons of oil- my mom for instance in her house- used 1500 gallons during a winter- EASILY.. and that was set at 70. Old house, no insulation, old furnace etc.
I was going to go with budget, but they can't lock me in a price, so I'm going to go with pre-buy, it messes up my finances for a few weeks, but in the end, I'll be ahead...
Brandy