My son and I have cruised disney, carnival and rc. Disney was our first cruise and nothing compares to disney (if you are a disney fan). Anyway we have taken a few more cruises with carnival and rc. We prefer carnival. We felt that RC didn't have as much activities for us. We like to do bingo and all the activities that they do in the area where they do bingo. RC I felt was more for upscale people and Carnival was more relaxed. We are not party animals. In fact this last cruise on carnival we went to one of the dancing areas and stayed a while. I would definitely do carnival again.