H&V or Mama Melrose??

[mickeygirlnc]

OK, I'm totally stressing over ADRs I've made for our Sept. trip. We have the Fantasmic package with dinner at Hollywood & Vine, but I'm wondering if I should try to change it for Mama Melrose...can you believe we don't have reservations for any Italian in Disney?

What are your suggestions? I haven't eaten at either restaurant..
Help please

 

[Golf4food]

Our last time at H&V was not very good, but that was Dec 2006, so it has been almost two years. Take it for what it is worth. If we were going to do a Fantasmic package again we would do Mama Melrose, but we more likely would just not do the package and show up early. We've done both ways.

 

[j-jhall]

We have the package as well and we are doing Mama Melrose's. I have heard some good things plus the menu looked better to me.