We were there in October as well. We also liked some aspects of FP"+" enough to get our first ever APs. Then, a week after we got home, tiering went into place. All bets were off.
I pulled up one of my posts from my spring break 2012 trip. I think we made RD a grand total of once, and we managed to ride every headliner with FPs. I forgot that we rode TSMM twice with FPs on the same day. I am mostly okay with 3 FPs (sufficient for everything but MK), and I don't have huge issues with not being able to re-ride. However, the no hopping and/or the tiers have to go. Without the tiers, I could deal with no hopping. If there were hopping, I could (almost) tolerate the tiers. As it stands, I will now have to make it before RD, or we'll be missing some headliners. And it makes me ornery, since FP"+" was supposed to allow you to sleep in.
I did love having FPs for Soarin, TT, and MS on arrival night. We got to EP that day at 5:30 and rode headliners with no wait. Fantastic. We loved not having to do the TSMM RD hustle or to have a designated FP runner. We also had great luck changing times around once we were in the parks (for everything but TSMM).
So, in October, for us, the positives of the new system outweighed the negatives. Now, not so much. I am spending a ridiculous amount of time here, because I want to figure out the best ways to manage our June trip. We are still going, and we are still going to have a great time, but I need to have realistic expectations.
I am most interested to see posts from guests from now going forward. I want to see real world examples from families (not necessarily from professional bloggers) who've used the system under the restrictions of tiering and with the additional load of all the offsiters using the system as well.
These conditions will likely be drastically different from what I encountered in October. I can tell that moving FPs same day is not what it was in October. I check
MDE frequently, and I've seen no availability for MS, ToT, Soarin', TT, and even Space Mtn as of mid-afternoon. In October, we could have made FPs for any of those well into the afternoon, but we were only competing with other resort guests at that time.
I do look at both positive and negative reports. I want to see what is and isn't working for everyone. I love hearing the rumors that hopping may be available. I hope that really does come true. But I do see what the "big deal" is for some people, especially for offsiters with spring break trips planned.