Our grand gathering group recently dined twice at Earl of Sandwich for dinner during our January 8-12 trip. We really liked the quality and portions of the meals, as well as the very reasonable prices. Some of the menu selections that we enjoyed most were the Earl's Club, Le Frenchy and Florentine sandwiches, the classic tuna salad with mixed greens and dressing and the yogurt parfaits.
Although we were fortunate to find a table large enough for our group, it seems the dining area lacks sufficient tables to accommodate big crowds. The restaurant was rather busy during our visit, and several diners were left waiting for a place to sit long after they picked up their food.
Also, the counter service process is somewhat disorganized, and made more complicated by having to return through the line to pick-up previous orders (salads) after you pay. Also, the absence of trays make carrying awkward items such as soups, salads and drinks unnecessarily inconvenient.
Despite these minor shortcomings, we would definitely return to Earl of Sandwich on our next trip.