In the past 25 years I have stayed off site 3 times and on site so many times I could not even begin to count, and for me....I would never stay off site again. IMO, it is a completely different vacation when you stay off site. You lose that feeling of total disney emersion. I always felt more like a day tripper when I stayed off site, it does not feel as though it is my home for the trip. Heck, I even stay on site when I am in the area for business and the seminars are held AT Courtyard by Marriott!! Doing it again this Sept, matter of fact, the seminar is at Courtyard by Marriott and I will be staying at WDW.