The problem is that senior management are all bean counters! The inmates are in charge of the asylum!
Walt Disney was an artist! Say what you will about him, Eisner, as I've said before, at least seemed determined to uphold the idea of Disney as something unique and a bit special -- something more than a Six Flags amusement park. He created the Disney Institute, which of course got destroyed.
The whole push, now, is to maximize profits by making sure to gear everything to the middle of the road masses. If it's too elitist (a wine dinner for 60 people, OMG!), get rid of it, unless somebody else is paying for it.
There is always a lot of "slush" money in a corporation that can be tossed at various things. I know. I work in management for a corporation (not in the entertainment industry.) Some of that was being thrown, IMO, toward the Festival and to the overall effort under Eisner to encourage those who previously would not have dreamed of spending a vacation at WDW (or any amusement park) to come see what all the fuss was about. They created new restaurants, hired great chefs, started a culinary training program, hired 300 sommeliers, and created a true magnet for people who otherwise would have spent their vacations elsewhere -- Napa Valley, a luxury cruise, an Italian villa, etc.
We, like others, actually fell for it. And, for a few years, it worked. But, Eisner left, there is obviously a new management team in place, and the idea now is numbers -- always numbers. Get as many people to the parks and resorts as possible, give them anything awful to eat -- so long as it's a buffet and there is tons of that awful food available, streamline all menus so that purchasing product is cheaper, there is less inventory to store and less waste due to spoilage.
We've seen it coming for the last 2-3 years with the
DDP, less elaborate and unique rides (how 'bout that DinoLand at AK -- every town has a carnival just like it), and now we see it with the F&W Festival. If I were in food and beverage at WDW, I'd seriously be looking elsewhere for employment because the writing is on the wall. If you want to spend your life turning out millions of Mickey waffles for the Chef Mickey breakfast buffet, WDW is for you. But, if your culinary aspirations are a bit higher, you're being abandoned by WDW.
Believe me, I don't spend thousands to travel to WDW for the F&W Festival for what I see this year! We were tempted to purchase DVC and are now glad we didn't. The thought of being locked into 40 years of attending a Festival like the one this year would really have me steamed!