Earl of Sandwich vs Potbelly Sandwich Works

[jenhelgren]

Is Earl of Sandwich compareable to Potbelly? We have Potbelly here at home but haven't tried Earl of Sandwich yet. Are the sandwiches around the same size? The prices seem reasonable so I am wondering how small the sandwiches are?? Thanks!

 

[CastawayJP]

Earl of Sandwich is much better! The sandwiches are large and delicious! I have always been disappointed by Potbelly...

 

[Minnesota!]

EoS is MUCH better (and I love Potbelly!). The bread is chewier, fresher. I think the EoS sandwiches are much bigger.

I had the BLT last week (yum) and it was VERY filling...

 

[TinkerwithDis]

Earl of Sandwich is so overrated. Their sandwiches are good, but nothing special! Nothing i'd go out of my way for, thats for sure. I vote team Pot Belly's!

 

[sabcook]

I think EOS is better than PB - more variety, better bread and, besides, you are eating at WDW so it has that extra pixie dust

 

[OKWJan]

WE love them both! You won't be disappointed at the Earl of Sandwich. That said, we always have to make at least one trip to Potbellies when we go back to Chicago. No Potbellies here in Florida .

 

[chigirl]

Potbelly is better than Earl of Sandwich, but EOS's servings ARE bigger...I like the taste of the meat at Potbelly better. Potbelly's oatmeal chocolate chip cookies are amazing!

 

[hmillerbarilla]

We love both.

We usually eat at Potbelly's at Midway airport in Chicago, and then at EOS at Disney!

I love the Wreck at Potbelly's and the All American at EOS.

Enjoy!

 

[Amunet]

Thank you, OP, for posting this!

DH and I have been wondering where we're going to eat at DTD when we arrive and I was thinking EoS. After reading the responses, we have decided to do it (okay, I decided ) Thank you!

 

[OrangeCountyCommuter]

Sorry, I vote for EOS. Potbelly has never really impressed me

 

[goofyintoronto]

Thank you, OP, for posting this!

DH and I have been wondering where we're going to eat at DTD when we arrive and I was thinking EoS. After reading the responses, we have decided to do it (okay, I decided ) Thank you!

I'd recommend Wolfgang Puck Express instead, which is not too far from EoS. Far better food. JMHO!

But if you had your heart set on a sandwich, then EoS is the place for you.