Counter service total $722. This includes ALL food & beverage purchases that weren't part of a TS meal. CS meals, snacks, cocktails at Epcot, a bottle of wine, the half & half we bought in the gift shop to keep in the room fridge, etc.
$2567 total for ALL food, beverage, and gratuities. That's about $350 more than last year, but I can't remember if I included the food from Universal in my WDW food tally last year. I don't think I did - I think I separated out the Universal costs because I was comparing costs for WDW to what the Dining Plans would have cost. If we had actually been able to go to an Imagineer dinner it would have added $255. Notice that this is nowhere NEAR $4000? The Sunrise Safari was $195, but that kind of straddled Recreation and Dining. Even if I include the Imagineer dinner and the Safari we are at $3017, and neither one of those is eligible for Dining Plan so they would have been additional OOP expenses anyway.
DxDDP would have been $3555, with no alcohol and no gratuities. The year we had DxDDP our tips were running about $50 per day, so figure another $750 for a ballpark total of $4305.
QSDP would have been $1575, which is DOUBLE what we spent on CS and snacks, and includes no alcohol.
I realize I didn't buy everything that the plan would have covered, but we did order everything we wanted. The point is, we come out WAAAAYYY ahead without a dining plan. At no point during our trip did any of us ever NOT get something we wanted to eat or drink. (Well, except that one dessert I didn't get at LTT, but that wasn't a money issue.

) We NEVER make DS order from the kid's menu - we allow him to make that choice at every meal. He is much happier that way.
Our CS cost would have been higher if we wouldn't have stayed CL, but it wouldn't have doubled. We ate breakfast in the lounge maybe 10 days, which was a savings of around $250. Paying OOP for breakfast all of those days STILL wouldn't have cost as much as the DxDDP base price.
All food & beverage and gratuities, INCLUDING paying for the Imagineer dinner, the Sunrise Safari AND OOP for 10 more CS breakfasts would have put us at about $3300 - $1000 LESS than DxDDP. And as we have already mentioned, the Safari and the Imagineer dinner are NOT covered by the dining plan! The DxDDP total would have been $4755 once the OOP costs of the excluded experiences were added in!
