College freshman here! I started school last week as a commuter. My school is about 25-35 minutes away. So far, I'm very happy with my decision to commute. I made my schedule so that I don't have Friday classes and my earliest class is at 10:00 AM so I don't have to worry about being late.
My mom didn't encourage me to live at home, or to live on campus. I'm sure she's happier with me home(My parents are divorced and it's just the two of us at home) but it was my decision. I love having my own room, my own bathroom, and coming home to my familiar house with my mom, my cats, and my dog. It doesn't mean I'm too immature to move out. I could've done it. I just knew I'd be happier at home. I think that living in a dorm with roommates would stress me out too much. Maybe it would be different if I could get a single room, but those don't exist on my campus. There's one building with doubles and triples, and the rest are all suites. Why should I pay an extra $10,000 a year to live 12 miles away when I don't want to?
I don't feel like I'll be missing out on anything. Maybe I'm wrong, but I think this is going to work for me. Two of my best friends are going to the same school as me. One of them lives on campus, one lives at home. Everyone is different. I'm making friends, I love my classes, I'm enjoying college. This is just what I think will work best for me.